A Sowing Advisory Under Conflicting Monsoon Forecasts
It is 20 June. The district agriculture officer of Nagaur must issue a sowing advisory for 1.8 lakh ha, mostly rainfed bajra and moth bean. IMD's extended-range forecast gives a 65% probability of above-normal rainfall over the next four weeks, but the monsoon has not advanced past 20°N and the 850 hPa wind field is weak. A private forecast subscribed by the state predicts a 15-day dry spell. Soil moisture in the top 30 cm is 40% of field capacity after a pre-monsoon shower. Canal water from the IGNP will not reach the district. Farmers have seed of a 75-day bajra variety and a 110-day castor variety; the kharif sowing window closes around 15 July for bajra and 31 July for castor. Early sowing before a dry spell risks germination failure; late sowing exposes the crop to terminal heat in September. The officer must decide what to recommend and how to phrase uncertainty.
1. What should the officer advise, and how should the two forecasts be weighed?
Read the worked answer
Advice: staggered, risk-spreading sowing rather than a single blanket date.
The two forecasts are not directly comparable. IMD's 65% probability is a probabilistic outlook for a large area; it does not mean that every block will receive rain in the next fortnight. The private forecast is a deterministic dry-spell warning with a shorter lead time. A 65% probability still leaves a 35% chance of below-normal rain, which is too high to justify sowing the entire 1.8 lakh ha on the strength of the outlook alone, especially with soil moisture at only 40% of field capacity.
A defensible advisory: (i) sow the short-duration 75-day bajra first, in the blocks that received the pre-monsoon shower, using treated seed and dry sowing where the soil is moist below 5 cm; (ii) hold back about one-third of the area for 8–10 days and reassess the 850 hPa winds and satellite cloud imagery; (iii) do not recommend castor at scale before 10 July, because its 110-day duration pushes harvest into September heat if sowing slips; use it only as a contingency if the monsoon revives late; (iv) keep moth bean as the low-risk filler crop. The advisory should state probabilities, not certainties, and give a clear 'if no rain by 5 July' trigger for switching to fodder or contingency crops.
2. Explain the atmospheric circulation features that control monsoon onset over western Rajasthan and why onset timing remains difficult to predict.
Read the worked answer
Onset over western Rajasthan is the last stage of a continental-scale seasonal transition.
Three features matter most. First, the ITCZ shifts northward and the heat low over northwest India deepens, establishing the pressure gradient that draws moist air inland. Second, the cross-equatorial Somali jet strengthens along the East African coast and turns eastward over the Arabian Sea, supplying the Arabian Sea branch of the monsoon; western Rajasthan depends heavily on this branch. Third, latent heating over the Tibetan Plateau and the Himalayan foothills reinforces the upper-level anticyclone and the downward branch that sustains the monsoon trough.
Onset over Rajasthan normally occurs in the first week of July, much later than Kerala, because the Arabian Sea branch must advance across Gujarat and the Aravalli region. The 850 hPa wind field mentioned in the case is a useful diagnostic: a weak jet means weak moisture flux, even if the probabilistic outlook is favourable.
Prediction is difficult for three reasons. Intraseasonal variability, including the Madhya Pradesh–MJO phase and break-monsoon periods, can produce a 15-day dry spell inside a season classified as 'above normal'. Convection is chaotic and models disagree at the 2–4 week range. And Rajasthan's rainfall is spatially patchy, so a district-level forecast cannot resolve which blocks will receive the first soaking rain. The officer should therefore treat the forecast as a probability statement, not a sowing instruction.