The Old-Age Home Question
The household in Tiruchi has five people. The grandmother is 86 and has moderate dementia; last month she wandered out and was found near the bus stand. The father, 68, is retired with a pension of ₹18,000. The mother, 64, has arthritis and manages the home. You are 22 and about to join a job in Bengaluru; your younger brother is in school. The grandmother is lucid in the mornings and says she does not want to "be a burden". A well-run registered old-age home six km away charges ₹22,000 a month, including physiotherapy and a doctor's weekly visit. A room in the house could be rented for ₹6,000. The father wants to admit her; the mother says it is "abandoning her" and adharma. There is no resident carer, and the house is empty from 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. on weekdays.
1. Identify the duties and values at stake - filial duty, ahimsa, autonomy and non-abandonment - and distinguish duty from guilt.
Read the worked answer
Duties: putra dharma, the son's duty of care, sharpened by the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007, which makes maintenance of a parent a legal obligation enforceable through tribunals. Ahimsa: not to leave a vulnerable person in danger, given that she was found near the bus stand. Autonomy: her stated wish not to be a burden must be weighed, but moderate dementia means morning lucidity is not full capacity to plan. The mother's own duty of care, at 64 with arthritis, is also real.
Non-abandonment is not the same as co-residence. The ethical question is whether she is safe, supervised and visited, not whether she sleeps in a particular room. Guilt is the feeling that one is bad; duty is the question of what is owed. Guilt produces either paralysis, as with the mother, or a hasty decision taken to relieve the feeling. The ethical test is: which arrangement gives her safety, dignity and continued family contact, and who bears which cost? That question can be answered; guilt cannot.
2. The mother says sending her to a home is adharma. Evaluate this claim.
Read the worked answer
The claim has a real basis. Indian family ethics has long treated care of the elderly as a debt that cannot be outsourced, and the image of an old-age home as abandonment is not mere sentiment. But it is not a complete account of dharma. Dharma is contextual (dharma sukshma): the same act can be adharma when done to escape responsibility, and dharma when it is the only way to provide the supervision a person needs.
Here the facts matter - a 64-year-old with arthritis, a ₹18,000 pension, a grandmother who wanders, no resident carer, and a house empty from 9 to 6. The mother's position, if it means keeping the grandmother alone at home while everyone is out, may itself create the ahimsa problem it claims to avoid. The stronger dharmic test is not "home or family" but "safety, dignity and continued relationship". A nearby home with daily visits, weekend stays and a shared cost can satisfy all three; a locked room with nobody present does not. The mother is right about the danger of abandonment and wrong to treat the building as the moral unit.
3. Propose a concrete decision and a six-month review plan, including how to honour the grandmother's own wishes and the legal obligation.
Read the worked answer
Decision: a six-month trial at the registered home six km away, funded by the pension, the ₹6,000 room rent and ₹6,000 from your new salary, with the family retaining the house and a room for her. Before admission, visit twice unannounced and check registration, staff ratio, physiotherapy, doctor visits, food, and a written care plan for dementia and wandering.
Contact: at least three visits a week on rotation, Sunday lunch at home, a daily video call; the mother must not be the sole visitor. Honour the grandmother's views by explaining the plan in the morning, recording her agreement, and treating any clear refusal as decisive. Legally, keep maintenance receipts; the 2007 Act obligation continues regardless of where she lives.
Review at one, three and six months on four measures: safety incidents, health and weight, her mood and stated preference, and the family's capacity. If the home fails on two measures, bring her back with paid daytime care at home. A decision with a built-in reversal is what dharma as a practice looks like.