I85PREP
⌘ K
FE-1 Constitutional Law study materials
FE-1 Constitutional Law study resources

FE-1 Constitutional Law practice questions

One question at a time. Build your FE-1 Constitutional Law understanding.

First 50 of 200 questions. Each one lists the choices, the correct answer, and an explanation. The checker at the top of this page saves progress in this browser when it is available.

Continue in the practice tool above to load more questions, 50 at a time.

Question 1Constitutional Law

Which clause of the U.S. Constitution makes federal law supreme over conflicting state law?

  1. The Supremacy Clause of Article VI Correct answer.
  2. The Full Faith and Credit Clause of Article IV
  3. The Commerce Clause of Article I
  4. The Necessary and Proper Clause of Article I

Explanation

Article VI declares that the Constitution, federal statutes, and treaties are the supreme law of the land, binding state judges notwithstanding contrary state law. This clause is the textual basis for preemption doctrine.

Question 2Constitutional Law

Under the constitutional structure, which branch holds the power to declare a federal statute unconstitutional as a matter of final judicial review?

  1. The Senate, through its advice and consent role
  2. The President, through the veto power
  3. The federal judiciary, through the courts' power to decide cases Correct answer.
  4. The states, through their ratification conventions

Explanation

Judicial review, established in Marbury v. Madison, rests on the courts' duty to decide cases according to the Constitution, which is superior to ordinary legislation. Neither the veto nor ratification gives another branch final authority to invalidate statutes.

Question 3Constitutional Law

A state enacts a tax that discriminates against out-of-state sellers of a good also produced in-state. Which constitutional doctrine most directly governs the validity of that tax?

  1. The Dormant Commerce Clause Correct answer.
  2. The Contracts Clause
  3. The Bill of Attainder Clause
  4. The Privileges or Immunities Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment

Explanation

The Dormant Commerce Clause limits state laws that discriminate against or unduly burden interstate commerce when Congress has not acted. Discriminatory taxes on out-of-state economic actors face a demanding standard and usually fail absent a legitimate local purpose.

Question 4Constitutional Law

Which standard of review applies to most classifications based on gender under the Equal Protection Clause?

  1. Absolute prohibition without exception
  2. Rational basis review
  3. Strict scrutiny
  4. Intermediate scrutiny Correct answer.

Explanation

Gender classifications receive intermediate scrutiny: the state must show an exceedingly persuasive justification, meaning the classification serves important governmental objectives and is substantially related to achieving them. Strict scrutiny is reserved for suspect classes such as race.

Question 5Constitutional Law

A state law requires all public schools to begin the day with a prayer drafted by the state legislature. Which Establishment Clause principle most directly condemns the law?

  1. Government may not compose official prayers for students to recite Correct answer.
  2. Government may not exempt religious objectors from neutral laws
  3. Government may not allow students to form religious clubs
  4. Government may not fund any secular school program

Explanation

Official state authorship of a prayer for school recitation involves the government in composing religious content, which the Establishment Clause forbids. The coercion of students in a public school setting compounds the violation.

Question 6Constitutional Law

Which constitutional provision supplies the primary textual basis for Congress's power to regulate activities that substantially affect interstate commerce?

  1. Article I, Section 8, Clause 3 Correct answer.
  2. Article IV, Section 1
  3. The Tenth Amendment
  4. Article II, Section 2, Clause 2

Explanation

Article I, Section 8, Clause 3 is the Commerce Clause, which the Supreme Court has read to reach activities that substantially affect interstate commerce. It is the principal source of federal economic regulatory power.

Question 7Constitutional Law

A criminal defendant is tried in a state court without counsel and without a valid waiver, and is sentenced to imprisonment. Under the Sixth Amendment as incorporated, which statement is correct?

  1. The conviction stands because counsel is required only on appeal
  2. The conviction stands because the Sixth Amendment applies only in federal court
  3. The conviction cannot stand because the right to counsel applies to felony prosecutions in state court Correct answer.
  4. The conviction stands because the defendant did not request counsel

Explanation

Gideon v. Wainwright incorporated the Sixth Amendment right to counsel against the states for felony prosecutions, and indigent defendants must be provided counsel. A waiver must be knowing and intelligent, so silence or failure to request does not forfeit the right.

Question 8Constitutional Law

Which amendment's Due Process Clause is the vehicle through which most provisions of the Bill of Rights have been applied to the states?

  1. The Ninth Amendment
  2. The Fifth Amendment
  3. The Fourteenth Amendment Correct answer.
  4. The Eleventh Amendment

Explanation

The Supreme Court has used the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process Clause to incorporate most Bill of Rights guarantees against the states. The Fifth Amendment's Due Process Clause constrains the federal government.

Question 9Constitutional Law

A police officer stops a car without probable cause or reasonable suspicion and finds contraband in plain view. The defendant moves to suppress. How should the court rule under current doctrine?

  1. Admit the evidence, because plain-view observations are always admissible regardless of how the officer arrived
  2. Suppress the evidence, because vehicle searches always require a warrant
  3. Admit the evidence, because traffic stops require no justification at all
  4. Suppress the evidence, because the stop was unlawful and the contraband was discovered through that illegality Correct answer.

Explanation

An investigatory stop requires reasonable suspicion, and evidence discovered as a direct result of an unlawful seizure is generally suppressed as fruit of the poisonous tree. The plain-view doctrine does not cure an antecedent constitutional violation.

Question 10Constitutional Law

A state grants a tax exemption to a religious publication but denies the same exemption to secular newspapers. Which Free Exercise and Establishment Clause problem is most directly presented?

  1. Viewpoint discrimination in a benefit scheme that burdens religious exercise while favoring secular speakers Correct answer.
  2. An establishment violation because any benefit to religion is forbidden
  3. A permissible accommodation because religion may never receive neutral benefits
  4. No issue, because tax exemptions are not subject to First Amendment review

Explanation

When a state creates a benefit and denies it solely because of the religious character of the recipient's speech, it burdens free exercise and discriminates based on viewpoint. Neutrality requires that religious speakers not be singled out for disadvantage.

Question 11Constitutional Law

A federal agency adjudicates a dispute and imposes a large civil penalty, with limited review by Article III courts. Which constitutional concern is most directly raised?

  1. Separation of powers and the Article III judicial power over adjudication and punishment Correct answer.
  2. The Bill of Attainder Clause
  3. The Contracts Clause
  4. The Third Amendment

Explanation

Assigning adjudicatory and punitive functions to non-Article III decisionmakers raises separation-of-powers questions about the scope of judicial power and the extent of court review. The concern is structural, not contractual or military-quartering related.

Question 12Constitutional Law

A city ordinance bans all signs on residential property except those the city administrator approves as consistent with community standards. Which doctrine most clearly invalidates the ordinance?

  1. The Guarantee Clause
  2. Prior restraint and unbridled discretion in a permit scheme affecting speech Correct answer.
  3. The Dormant Commerce Clause
  4. The Presentment Clause

Explanation

A licensing scheme that gives an official unfettered discretion to permit or deny expressive activity operates as an unconstitutional prior restraint. Speech regulations must contain narrow, objective standards and procedural safeguards.

Question 13Constitutional Law

Congress conditions receipt of federal highway funds on a state's adoption of a specified speed limit. Which test governs whether the condition is a permissible exercise of the spending power?

  1. The condition must serve the general welfare, be unambiguous, relate to the federal interest, and not coerce the state Correct answer.
  2. The condition must be approved by a two-thirds vote of the states
  3. The condition must be enacted as a treaty
  4. The condition must be reviewed under strict scrutiny as a racial classification

Explanation

Spending Clause conditions are valid when they promote the general welfare, are stated clearly, are related to the federal interest in the program, and do not cross the line from encouragement into coercion. The test is a structural federalism inquiry, not a racial one.

Question 14Constitutional Law

A state imposes a term limit on its own members of Congress, arguing that it may regulate elections. Which holding governs the validity of that measure?

  1. The measure is invalid because states may never regulate federal elections
  2. The measure is invalid because the Qualifications Clauses set exclusive constitutional requirements for members of Congress Correct answer.
  3. The measure is valid because states control the times, places, and manner of elections
  4. The measure is valid because it was enacted by popular referendum

Explanation

The Supreme Court has held that the Qualifications Clauses fix the exclusive constitutional qualifications for members of Congress, so states cannot add term limits. The Elections Clause power over times, places, and manner does not include altering qualifications.

Question 15Constitutional Law

A defendant's confession follows a police promise of leniency that makes the statement involuntary. Which constitutional guarantee is the primary basis for excluding the confession?

  1. The Fourteenth Amendment's Privileges or Immunities Clause
  2. The Sixth Amendment's Speedy Trial Clause
  3. The Eighth Amendment's Excessive Fines Clause
  4. The Due Process Clause's prohibition on coerced confessions Correct answer.

Explanation

Coerced confessions are excluded under the Due Process Clause because they are unreliable and offend fundamental fairness. Voluntariness is assessed from the totality of the circumstances, including police promises and pressure.

Question 16Constitutional Law

A state law forbids the sale of any product made from a protected animal, including products imported from other states, to protect a species within the state. Which analysis best applies?

  1. The law may be valid if it regulates evenhandedly and its burden on interstate commerce is not clearly excessive relative to legitimate local benefits Correct answer.
  2. The law is automatically valid because it concerns animals rather than commerce
  3. The law is valid only if Congress expressly authorizes it in advance
  4. The law is automatically invalid because it touches imported goods

Explanation

Nondiscriminatory state environmental or conservation measures are evaluated under a balancing approach asking whether the local benefit justifies the burden on interstate commerce. Discriminatory or protectionist measures face stricter scrutiny.

Question 17Constitutional Law

A public university denies official recognition to a student religious group because its membership and leadership are limited to members of one faith. Which constitutional principle is most relevant?

  1. The Contracts Clause
  2. The group's expressive association and free speech rights, weighed against the school's interest in nondiscrimination Correct answer.
  3. The Third Amendment
  4. The Establishment Clause's absolute bar on religious student groups

Explanation

Excluding a religious group from generally available recognition benefits burdens expressive association and speech, and the school must show a sufficiently important interest served by narrow means. The Establishment Clause does not require excluding religious groups from neutral benefits.

Question 18Constitutional Law

A state requires a woman to notify her spouse before obtaining an abortion and provides no exception for medical emergencies. Which constitutional analysis applies?

  1. The requirement is invalid because states may never regulate abortion in any respect
  2. The requirement is valid because states may regulate all medical procedures without review
  3. The requirement is valid because spouses have a constitutional veto
  4. The requirement is invalid because it unduly burdens the right and lacks an emergency exception Correct answer.

Explanation

Spousal notification rules have been held to impose an undue burden on the liberty interest, particularly without an exception for medical emergencies. The analysis asks whether the regulation creates substantial obstacles to the protected decision.

Question 19Constitutional Law

A city council members' prayer practice opens each session with a sectarian prayer, and the policy permits any volunteer to give an invocation without review of content. Which Establishment Clause approach most directly governs?

  1. The practice is per se valid because prayers are traditional
  2. The practice is governed by the Contracts Clause
  3. The practice is assessed for whether it coerces participation or affiliates the government with a particular faith in a legislative setting Correct answer.
  4. The practice is per se invalid because any prayer is forbidden

Explanation

Legislative prayer is analyzed under Establishment Clause principles that consider coercion, denominational favoritism, and the setting's history. The mere presence of prayer is not automatically valid or invalid; the specifics of the policy and practice matter.

Question 20Constitutional Law

A federal statute delegates to an agency the power to set criminal penalties for violations of rules the agency itself writes, with no intelligible standard. Which constitutional challenge is strongest?

  1. A bill of attainder challenge
  2. A Contracts Clause challenge
  3. An excessive delegation challenge under the separation of powers Correct answer.
  4. A Third Amendment challenge

Explanation

Delegating legislative power without an intelligible principle raises nondelegation concerns grounded in separation of powers, especially where criminal penalties are involved. The doctrine requires Congress to provide meaningful standards to guide agency discretion.

Question 21Constitutional Law

Congress invokes its enforcement power under Section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment to create a cause of action broader than the Supreme Court's interpretation of the Equal Protection Clause. Which principle governs?

  1. Congress may enforce the amendment only through treaties
  2. Congress may enforce the amendment but may not expand the substantive guarantees beyond the Court's interpretation Correct answer.
  3. Congress may redefine constitutional rights whenever it disagrees with the Court
  4. Congress has no enforcement power under the Fourteenth Amendment

Explanation

Section 5 permits Congress to enact congruent and proportional legislation to remedy or prevent constitutional violations, but not to create new substantive rights beyond the Court's interpretation. The enforcement power is remedial and preventive, not definitional.

Question 22Constitutional Law

A state imposes a higher tax on out-of-state insurance companies than on domestic ones, and Congress has enacted a statute expressly permitting state regulation of insurance. Which result follows?

  1. The state tax is invalid because insurance is never commerce
  2. The state tax is valid because the Privileges and Immunities Clause protects corporations
  3. The state tax is invalid because the Dormant Commerce Clause always forbids discrimination
  4. The state tax may stand because Congress removed the Dormant Commerce Clause barrier Correct answer.

Explanation

When Congress affirmatively authorizes state regulation, the Dormant Commerce Clause no longer bars the state action. The dormant doctrine applies only in the absence of congressional direction.

Question 23Constitutional Law

A state constitutional amendment forbids state courts from considering federal constitutional claims in certain cases, and the state argues that its courts are the final arbiters of federal law. Which principle resolves the conflict?

  1. State courts may disregard federal precedent when state law conflicts
  2. State constitutional amendments automatically repeal federal law
  3. Federal law is supreme, and state courts must follow U.S. Supreme Court interpretation of federal constitutional questions Correct answer.
  4. Federal courts lack jurisdiction over state court decisions involving federal questions

Explanation

The Supremacy Clause and the appellate jurisdiction of the U.S. Supreme Court ensure that federal constitutional interpretation binds state courts. State law cannot authorize state courts to disregard controlling federal precedent.

Question 24Constitutional Law

A federal statute requires states to either enact a specified waste-disposal program or lose all federal funding for unrelated education programs. Which doctrine is most directly implicated?

  1. The Bill of Attainder Clause
  2. The Third Amendment
  3. The anti-commandeering doctrine and the coercion limits on conditional spending Correct answer.
  4. The Dormant Commerce Clause only

Explanation

Conditions that commandeer state legislatures or cross into economic coercion raise federalism limits on the spending power. The analysis asks whether the condition compels states to enact a federal program or leaves them a genuine choice.

Question 25Constitutional Law

A state law grants a property tax exemption to a religious organization's buildings used for worship but denies it to buildings used for religious education. Which principle governs the challenge?

  1. The state may not discriminate among religious uses without a compelling justification, and neutral treatment of religious property uses is required Correct answer.
  2. The state may discriminate because tax policy is unreviewable
  3. The state may deny all religious exemptions because the Establishment Clause forbids them
  4. The state may prefer worship over education because worship is more central to religion

Explanation

Differential treatment of religious uses raises Establishment and Free Exercise concerns, and the state must justify distinctions among religious activities with a compelling interest. Neutrality generally requires comparable treatment of religious property uses.

Question 26Constitutional Law

Which clause of the Constitution makes federal law supreme over conflicting state law?

  1. The Full Faith and Credit Clause of Article IV
  2. The Supremacy Clause of Article VI Correct answer.
  3. The Commerce Clause of Article I
  4. The Tenth Amendment reservation of powers

Explanation

Article VI declares that the Constitution, federal statutes, and treaties are the supreme law of the land, binding state judges notwithstanding contrary state law. This clause is the textual foundation for preemption doctrine.

Question 27Constitutional Law

Under Article III, which of the following is a requirement for a federal court to hear a case?

  1. The Attorney General must certify that the case is of national importance
  2. The case must involve a federal statute rather than the Constitution
  3. The plaintiff must have standing, meaning a concrete injury traceable to the defendant and redressable by the court Correct answer.
  4. The parties must be citizens of the same state

Explanation

Article III's case-or-controversy limitation requires a plaintiff to show injury in fact, causation, and redressability. Without standing, a federal court lacks jurisdiction regardless of the merits.

Question 28Constitutional Law

The Bill of Rights originally limited the actions of which government?

  1. Only the states
  2. Only state and local governments, not the federal government
  3. Both the federal government and the states equally
  4. Only the federal government Correct answer.

Explanation

As ratified, the Bill of Rights restrained the federal government; Barron v. Baltimore held that it did not apply to the states. Selective incorporation through the Fourteenth Amendment later extended most protections to the states.

Question 29Constitutional Law

Which standard of review applies to most classifications based on gender?

  1. Strict scrutiny
  2. Absolute prohibition without exception
  3. Rational basis review
  4. Intermediate scrutiny Correct answer.

Explanation

Gender classifications are evaluated under intermediate scrutiny, requiring an exceedingly persuasive justification and a substantial relationship to important governmental objectives. Courts have struck down many gender-based rules under this standard.

Question 30Constitutional Law

The First Amendment's Establishment Clause prohibits Congress from doing what?

  1. Funding fire and police protection for houses of worship on the same terms as other buildings
  2. Making any law respecting an establishment of religion Correct answer.
  3. Allowing religious groups to incorporate as nonprofit entities
  4. Permitting voluntary student prayer in any setting

Explanation

The text bars laws respecting an establishment of religion, and the Supreme Court has applied that bar to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment. Neutral programs providing general services on equal terms have generally been upheld.

Question 31Constitutional Law

Which constitutional doctrine permits a state to regulate conduct occurring outside its borders when the conduct produces effects within the state?

  1. The Contracts Clause
  2. The effects test under the Commerce Clause Correct answer.
  3. The Privileges and Immunities Clause of Article IV
  4. The dormant Commerce Clause

Explanation

The effects test allows regulation of out-of-state conduct that has a substantial effect within the regulating state, subject to Commerce Clause limits. It reflects the reach of state power over interstate activity.

Question 32Constitutional Law

The President's power to make treaties requires what additional step to become effective as supreme law?

  1. A national referendum
  2. Ratification by a majority of state legislatures
  3. Approval by a majority of the House of Representatives
  4. Advice and consent of two-thirds of the Senate Correct answer.

Explanation

Article II requires the President to obtain the advice and consent of two-thirds of the Senate present for a treaty. Once ratified, treaties are supreme law under Article VI.

Question 33Constitutional Law

Which of the following best describes the constitutional status of the privilege against self-incrimination in civil proceedings?

  1. It does not apply because the Fifth Amendment protects only against compelled testimonial self-incrimination in criminal cases, though testimony may still be compelled with use immunity Correct answer.
  2. It applies fully in civil proceedings because the Fifth Amendment contains no limitation
  3. It applies only in federal administrative hearings and never in state civil litigation
  4. It applies only when the witness is a party to the civil suit

Explanation

The Fifth Amendment protects against compelled testimonial self-incrimination in criminal matters; in civil proceedings a witness may be compelled to testify if granted use immunity. The protection is not limited to parties or to federal forums.

Question 34Constitutional Law

A state enacts a statute requiring all employers with more than fifty employees to provide twelve weeks of unpaid family leave. A trade association of small manufacturers challenges the law, arguing that federal labor law occupies the field. Which analytical framework applies?

  1. The court asks whether the state law was approved by the Secretary of Labor
  2. The court applies strict scrutiny because the law affects employment
  3. The court asks whether Congress expressed a clear intent to preempt the field or whether state law conflicts with federal law Correct answer.
  4. The court applies the rational basis test without considering federal law

Explanation

Preemption analysis asks whether Congress intended to occupy the field, whether compliance with both laws is impossible, or whether state law obstructs federal purposes. The absence of an express preemption clause does not end the inquiry.

Question 35Constitutional Law

A federal statute creates a new private right of action against state officials for violations of a federal environmental standard. A state argues that the statute violates the Eleventh Amendment. Which principle governs?

  1. States may be sued whenever a federal statute creates a cause of action
  2. Congress may abrogate state sovereign immunity only when acting under a valid exercise of power, such as Section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment Correct answer.
  3. State sovereign immunity applies only to suits for money damages and never to prospective relief
  4. The Eleventh Amendment bars all suits against states in any court, including state courts

Explanation

Congress may abrogate Eleventh Amendment immunity only through a valid exercise of enforcement power, and the Court has generally confined this to Section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment. Prospective relief against state officers under Ex parte Young remains available in some circumstances.

Question 36Constitutional Law

A state university adopts an admissions policy that awards points based on race to achieve diversity. A rejected applicant challenges the policy. Which standard applies?

  1. No review, because states may classify however they wish in education
  2. Rational basis review, because universities have broad discretion
  3. Strict scrutiny, requiring the policy to be narrowly tailored to a compelling interest Correct answer.
  4. Intermediate scrutiny, because education is an important government interest

Explanation

Racial classifications by state actors are subject to strict scrutiny, and the Court has recognized diversity as a compelling interest only when pursued through narrowly tailored means. The policy must not use race as a mechanical plus factor in a way that fails narrow tailoring.

Question 37Constitutional Law

A state requires candidates for state office to have lived in the state for ten years. A long-time resident of another state challenges the requirement. Which clause is most directly implicated?

  1. The Bill of Attainder Clause of Article I
  2. The Guarantee Clause of Article IV
  3. The Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment
  4. The Privileges and Immunities Clause of Article IV Correct answer.

Explanation

The Privileges and Immunities Clause bars states from discriminating against nonresidents in fundamental rights, and durational residency requirements for state office have been struck down as violating it. The right to seek public office is treated as fundamental for these purposes.

Question 38Constitutional Law

A state law prohibits picketing within 100 feet of a funeral home during a funeral. A group challenges the law. Which standard governs?

  1. Intermediate scrutiny, because the law regulates expressive conduct in a public forum Correct answer.
  2. No First Amendment scrutiny, because picketing is conduct rather than speech
  3. Rational basis review, because the law concerns public safety
  4. Strict scrutiny, because all time, place, and manner regulations are presumptively invalid

Explanation

Content-neutral time, place, and manner regulations of speech in public forums must serve a significant interest, be narrowly tailored, and leave open ample alternatives. Such regulations are reviewed under intermediate scrutiny, and funeral picketing laws have been upheld on that basis.

Question 39Constitutional Law

A state imposes a tax on a federal contractor's income derived from work performed for a federal agency within the state. The contractor argues the tax is unconstitutional. Which principle applies?

  1. The Commerce Clause bars all state taxes on contractors
  2. The Contracts Clause bars the state from taxing federal contracts
  3. The Sixteenth Amendment prohibits state income taxes on federal employees
  4. The intergovernmental tax immunity doctrine bars state taxes that discriminate against the federal government or burden its operations Correct answer.

Explanation

Intergovernmental tax immunity prohibits state taxes that discriminate against the federal government or impose a substantial burden on its operations. Nondiscriminatory taxes on federal contractors' income may be permissible.

Question 40Constitutional Law

A state enacts a law that requires all state employees to retire at age 65, with no exceptions. Which standard applies to a challenge under the Equal Protection Clause?

  1. Strict scrutiny, because the law affects fundamental rights
  2. Strict scrutiny, because the law affects employment
  3. Intermediate scrutiny, because age is a quasi-suspect class
  4. Rational basis review, because age is not a suspect or quasi-suspect classification Correct answer.

Explanation

Age classifications are reviewed under rational basis, and mandatory retirement rules for state employees have generally been upheld. Courts ask only whether the classification is rationally related to a legitimate government interest.

Question 41Constitutional Law

A state passes a law prohibiting the sale of gasoline-powered cars beginning in 2030. A group challenges the law under the dormant Commerce Clause. Which inquiry is central?

  1. Whether the law is supported by a majority of state voters
  2. Whether the law was enacted by a supermajority of the legislature
  3. Whether the law is consistent with the state constitution
  4. Whether the law discriminates against or unduly burdens interstate commerce Correct answer.

Explanation

The dormant Commerce Clause prohibits state laws that discriminate against interstate commerce or impose undue burdens on it. A facially neutral law may still be invalid if it burdens interstate commerce excessively relative to local benefits.

Question 42Constitutional Law

A defendant is convicted after the trial court excludes evidence that the defendant claims would have impeached a key prosecution witness. Which constitutional guarantee is most directly implicated?

  1. The Sixth Amendment right to confront witnesses and present a defense Correct answer.
  2. The Eighth Amendment prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment
  3. The Contracts Clause of Article I
  4. The Grand Jury Clause of the Fifth Amendment

Explanation

The Compulsory Process and Confrontation Clauses protect a defendant's ability to present evidence and cross-examine adverse witnesses. Erroneous exclusion of material impeachment evidence can violate these rights.

Question 43Constitutional Law

A state imposes a one-year residency requirement before a new resident may receive welfare benefits. Which standard applies to a challenge under the Privileges or Immunities Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment?

  1. Rational basis review, because welfare benefits are not a fundamental right
  2. No review, because states may set welfare eligibility freely
  3. Intermediate scrutiny, because welfare is an important interest
  4. Strict scrutiny, because the law penalizes the right to travel Correct answer.

Explanation

Durational residency requirements that penalize the right to travel are subject to strict scrutiny and are generally invalid. The right to travel is a fundamental right, and welfare benefits cannot be conditioned on length of residence.

Question 44Constitutional Law

A city enacts an ordinance prohibiting any person from sleeping in public parks at night. A homeless advocacy group challenges the ordinance as cruel and unusual punishment. Which principle is most relevant?

  1. The Eighth Amendment prohibits any ordinance regulating public parks
  2. The Eighth Amendment prohibits punishing status rather than conduct, so an ordinance may not criminalize the status of homelessness itself Correct answer.
  3. The Eighth Amendment applies only to federal prisons
  4. The Eighth Amendment prohibits all laws that affect homeless individuals

Explanation

The Court has held that the Eighth Amendment prohibits punishing a person for status, such as being addicted to narcotics, rather than for conduct. Ordinances regulating sleeping in public raise questions about whether they punish status or conduct.

Question 45Constitutional Law

A federal statute authorizes the President to freeze the assets of any person the President determines poses a threat to national security, with no judicial review. Which constitutional issue is most directly raised?

  1. Whether the statute violates the Contracts Clause
  2. Whether the statute violates due process by foreclosing meaningful review Correct answer.
  3. Whether the statute violates the Bill of Attainder Clause
  4. Whether the statute violates the Guarantee Clause

Explanation

Due process generally requires notice and an opportunity to be heard before deprivations of property, and statutes foreclosing all review raise serious procedural due process concerns. National security interests may justify limited procedures but not the elimination of all review.

Question 46Constitutional Law

Congress enacts a statute requiring states to either adopt a uniform federal testing regime for public schools or forfeit all federal education funding. Which doctrine governs the challenge?

  1. The anti-commandeering doctrine and the spending power conditions test Correct answer.
  2. The Privileges or Immunities Clause
  3. The Bill of Attainder Clause
  4. The dormant Commerce Clause

Explanation

Spending conditions must serve the general welfare, be unambiguous, relate to the federal interest, and not coerce states. A condition requiring adoption of a federal program may also raise anti-commandeering concerns if it compels state legislative action.

Question 47Constitutional Law

A state court convicts a defendant after admitting a confession obtained during a six-hour interrogation without counsel, after the defendant had invoked the right to counsel. Which rule governs?

  1. Police may continue interrogation as long as the defendant is not physically coerced
  2. The confession is admissible if the defendant was read Miranda warnings at any point
  3. The right to counsel attaches only at trial, so pre-trial interrogation is unrestricted
  4. Once the right to counsel is invoked, police may not initiate further interrogation until counsel is present or the defendant initiates contact Correct answer.

Explanation

Under Edwards v. Arizona, once an accused invokes the right to counsel, police may not initiate further interrogation until counsel is provided or the accused initiates further communication. A confession obtained in violation is inadmissible in the prosecution's case-in-chief.

Question 48Constitutional Law

A state law grants a tax credit to parents who send their children to religious schools. A taxpayer challenges the credit as an establishment of religion. Which principle governs?

  1. The credit is valid if it is neutral with respect to religion and provides assistance to a broad class of beneficiaries defined without reference to religion Correct answer.
  2. The credit is valid only if the state legislature unanimously approves it
  3. The credit is invalid because tax credits are equivalent to direct expenditures in all cases
  4. The credit is invalid because any aid that reaches religious schools violates the Establishment Clause

Explanation

In Zelman and subsequent cases, the Court upheld tax credits and voucher programs that were neutral toward religion and available to a broad class of beneficiaries whose choices included religious and secular options. The key is private choice and neutrality, not the absence of any aid reaching religious institutions.

Question 49Constitutional Law

A state enacts a law requiring all persons to carry a state-issued identification card at all times and to produce it on demand by any police officer. Which constitutional challenge is strongest?

  1. A Guarantee Clause challenge because the law interferes with republican government
  2. A Contracts Clause challenge because the law impairs existing contracts
  3. A First Amendment challenge because identification cards are expressive
  4. A Fourth Amendment challenge to suspicionless stops and a Fourteenth Amendment due process challenge to vague standards Correct answer.

Explanation

A law authorizing stops without reasonable suspicion implicates the Fourth Amendment, and standards permitting officers to demand identification without clear limits raise vagueness concerns under the Due Process Clause. The strongest challenge combines these doctrines rather than relying on unrelated clauses.

Question 50Constitutional Law

Under Article III, which of the following is required for a federal court to hear a case?

  1. Consent of the state court that would otherwise hear the matter
  2. Approval of the case by the Solicitor General
  3. A presidential referral of the dispute to the judiciary
  4. A federal question or diversity of citizenship plus the statutory amount in controversy Correct answer.

Explanation

Article III extends the judicial power to cases arising under federal law and to controversies between citizens of different states, and Congress has implemented diversity jurisdiction with an amount-in-controversy threshold. Jurisdiction also requires a live case or controversy, but no executive or state consent.