Two Answers About Niko
Ms. Ortiz reads her class a four-sentence story: 'Niko packed his bag the night before. In the morning he checked it three times. At the bus stop he held the strap with both hands. When the bus arrived, he let three other children go first.' She asks, 'How does Niko feel about starting at his new school?' Devon says, 'Excited, because he packed early.' Priya says, 'Nervous, because he keeps checking his bag and he waits.' Ms. Ortiz writes both answers on the board. Four students raise hands for Devon and two for Priya. She does not take a vote. Instead she asks each group to point to one sentence and explain what it shows about Niko. One student adds, 'I felt nervous on my first day, so I know how Niko feels.' Ms. Ortiz says that is worth sharing, but it is not yet evidence about Niko.
1. Which answer does the story support better, and which single sentence is the strongest evidence? Explain why the other answer is weaker.
Read the worked answer
Priya's answer is better supported.
- Strongest evidence: 'In the morning he checked it three times.' Checking repeatedly is a sign of worry, not of looking forward to something.
- Supporting evidence: 'he held the strap with both hands' shows him holding on tightly, and 'he let three other children go first' shows him hanging back instead of rushing on.
Why Devon's answer is weaker: his sentence is 'Niko packed his bag the night before.' That sentence can point either way. A child who is excited might pack early, and so might a child who is worried about forgetting something. Evidence that fits both answers cannot decide between them.
The judgment being tested: the best answer is not the one with the loudest single sentence, but the one that the whole story, sentence by sentence, points toward.
2. A student says, 'I felt nervous on my first day, so I know how Niko feels.' Explain why Ms. Ortiz says this is not yet evidence about Niko, and what the student should do instead.
Read the worked answer
Why it does not count yet: the sentence tells us about the reader, not about Niko. Two readers could have felt opposite things on a first day, so a personal feeling cannot settle a question about a character. The question asks what the story shows.
What to do instead:
- Treat the feeling as a guess or a prediction, not a proof.
- Go back to the text and look for words that match the guess, such as checked it three times or held the strap with both hands.
- If no sentence matches, change the guess.
A useful sentence for the class: 'Your own feelings can help you think of an answer, but only the story can support it.'
3. Ms. Ortiz wants a sentence that does not help decide the question. Which sentence is the weakest evidence, and how could the class use it as a lesson?
Read the worked answer
Weakest sentence: 'Niko packed his bag the night before.' It is the only sentence that does not show how Niko acts when other people are around, and packing early is something both a nervous child and an excited child might do.
The class could sort the four sentences into three piles:
- Points to nervous: checked it three times; held the strap with both hands; let others go first.
- Points to excited: none clearly.
- Points both ways or neither: packed the night before.
The lesson: evidence is not just 'a sentence from the story.' Strong evidence narrows the answer, and weak evidence leaves two answers standing. Sorting by strength is the skill being practiced, not finding any quotation at all.