Five Good Days and a Lost Weekend
A 38-year-old father of two wants to lose 9 kg. He describes a reliable pattern: Monday through Thursday he eats 'clean' - chicken, rice, vegetables, no snacks - and by Friday evening he is eating chips, ordering takeout, drinking four or five beers, and continuing through Sunday. Sunday night he feels disgusted, vows to 'start fresh,' and cuts carbs and portions on Monday. He has tried keto (10 weeks, lost 6 kg, regained 7), 16:8 fasting, and a meal-prep service. He says, 'I have no willpower. Just tell me what to eat and I'll do it.' His wife is supportive, but his job involves client dinners twice a month and travel one week per quarter.
1. What is the real target behavior here, and why is prescribing another diet the wrong move?
Read the worked answer
The target is the weekly restriction-overconsumption cycle, not the food list. Four rigid days plus three days of roughly 3,500–5,000 extra kcal nets out near maintenance - which is why his weight is not moving. A new meal plan would feed the same cycle and give him another thing to 'fail' at.
Estimate the scale: if the weekend adds roughly 12,000 kcal above baseline, that is close to 1.5 kg of fat per month being cancelled by weekday restriction.
Behavioral targets: Friday-to-Sunday structure - a planned protein breakfast, one planned treat, a drink cap such as two beers plus water in between, a Saturday walk - and, critically, no Monday compensation. Removing the Monday cut is itself the intervention, because the restriction is what builds the Friday pressure.
Frame it as a two-week experiment rather than a rule: he logs only Friday through Sunday and brings the data. Name the abstinence violation effect - 'I ruined it' thinking turns one meal into a three-day relapse. Also challenge the 'no willpower' story directly: he has followed strict plans for 10 weeks, so the issue is plan and environment design, not character.
2. Describe the behavior-change techniques you would use, including how you would handle client dinners and travel.
Read the worked answer
Self-monitoring: weekend-only logging for two weeks, framed as data collection with no judgment, to identify the actual triggers - time of day, hunger, alcohol, boredom, or family routine.
Implementation intentions: 'If it is Friday after 6 pm, then I pour a sparkling water and plate one portion of chips.' 'If we order takeout, then I order the grilled option and one side.' 'If I have a client dinner, then I have two drinks maximum with water between them.'
Stimulus control: do not stock chips at home; decide the takeout order before Friday evening. Habit stacking: a family walk after Friday dinner. Weekly review: ten minutes, what worked, one change for the coming week.
Motivational interviewing: ask what he wants his weekends to feel like and what he wants his kids to see, so the goals are his.
Pre-plan the twice-monthly dinners and quarterly travel: a protein-first ordering script and a drink limit decided in advance, not negotiated at the table. Track process measures - weekend logs completed, drink cap met - before tracking weight, so early wins are visible.
3. He calls on Friday night after eating an entire takeout meal and says the week is ruined. What do you say and do?
Read the worked answer
Defuse first with arithmetic: one takeout meal is roughly 1,200–1,500 kcal, about 0.15–0.2 kg of fat. It cannot undo four days, and the week is not ruined.
Block compensation: no Monday carb cut, no extra cardio, no skipped breakfast. That compensation is precisely the mechanism that produces the next binge, so preventing it matters more than the meal itself.
Normalize and reframe: this is data, not failure. Ask what happened in the two hours beforehand - a skipped lunch, a hard meeting, a conflict at home? Then adjust the plan to that trigger rather than adding a rule.
Name the lapse-versus-relapse distinction explicitly, and reinforce that he called instead of hiding it, which is new behavior worth praising.
Close on the next meal, not the next week: what is breakfast tomorrow, and when is the Saturday walk. Keep the conversation short; the goal is to return him to the plan within hours, not to process the entire weekend.