The Client Who Is Disappearing Before Renewal
Devon is 38, a night-shift nurse and parent of two. He has been coaching with you for 12 weeks at $160/month; his goal is to lose 20 lb. He lost 7 lb in the first 8 weeks, then 1 lb in the next 6. Of the last 6 scheduled sessions, he attended 3, cancelled 2 late, and no-showed 1. He logged food 2 of 7 days and his step count fell from about 7,000 to 3,500. He writes, 'Work has been crazy-I'll get back on track,' and replies about 2 days later. The scale is up 1.5 lb, he reports 5 hours of sleep, and he mentions cravings. His monthly renewal is in 5 days. He has not asked to cancel.
1. What stage of change or ambivalence does this look like, and what coaching errors should you avoid in your next message? Explain your reasoning.
Read the worked answer
This looks like ambivalence and low readiness under stress, not laziness. The dip in logging, steps, and attendance after early success suggests competing demands and possibly all-or-nothing thinking. Coaching errors to avoid: lecturing, shaming, threatening to cancel, over-messaging, or immediately pushing a new meal plan. Those increase defensiveness. I would also avoid interpreting the 1.5-lb gain as fat gain; 5 hours of sleep and night shifts affect appetite, water, and adherence. The renewal in 5 days is a business issue, but the first conversation should be about what he wants, not a sales pitch. I would check for depression or medical issues if sleep and function are declining, and refer if needed. The key is to separate the relationship from the plan: keep the door open, reduce demands, and ask permission before giving advice.
2. Write the agenda and key questions for a 20-minute check-in that uses motivational interviewing rather than a lecture.
Read the worked answer
Open with: 'I have noticed the last few weeks have been hard. Can we talk about what would actually help right now?' Ask: 'What has been getting in the way?' 'What matters most to you about your health in the next month?' 'On a 0–10 scale, how ready are you to log food this week?' 'What would make that a 6 instead of a 4?' Reflect back: 'So work has been unpredictable and you are exhausted, and you do not want to abandon this.' Summarize. Then ask permission: 'Would it be okay if we simplified the plan to two things?' Avoid a 10-point lecture. End with a specific next step he chooses: one 10-minute walk after shifts or one protein anchor at breakfast. Set a 20-minute call, not a text thread. The goal is to elicit his reasons, not to convince him.
3. Propose a 4-week revised accountability and service plan, including what to do about the renewal in 5 days.
Read the worked answer
For 4 weeks, reduce to two sessions per week and one habit: a 5-minute walk or one protein-focused meal. Replace daily logging with a two-question check-in (sleep, energy) and a weekly 10-minute call. Use asynchronous voice notes rather than multiple texts. For renewal: since he has not asked to cancel, do not auto-charge without a conversation. Offer a 4-week reset at the same rate or a pause; be transparent about the deadline. If he chooses to pause, keep the relationship and set a check-in date. If he cancels, offer a summary and an open return. This protects trust and reduces chargeback risk. The business decision follows the coaching decision: do not use the payment as leverage.