JNCIA-Design study materials
JNCIA-Design study resources

PoE Budget and Cross-Floor Roaming in an Office Retrofit

JNCIA-Design · Put your knowledge to work in context.

All case studies

PoE Budget and Cross-Floor Roaming in an Office Retrofit

An insurance firm is retrofitting three floors of a 1990s office block: 640 assigned seats, about 1,100 devices at the Monday 10:00 peak, and 72 Wi-Fi 6E access points (24 per floor) that draw 25.5 W each when the 6 GHz radio and 802.3bt are active. Each IDF holds six 48-port access switches with a 740 W PoE budget, fed by a single 30 A 208 V UPS circuit; a seventh switch is planned for growth. Desk phones are 802.3af at 12.9 W, 20 per switch, and eight legacy 802.3af cameras at 15.4 W hang off floor 1. Users on floor 3 report 3–5 second voice drops whenever they walk to the stairwell and reappear on floor 2; WLC logs show those clients re-running DHCP at the moment of the drop. Guest Wi-Fi is bridged onto the corporate VLAN because, in the words of the outgoing contractor, it was easier.

1. Show whether the per-closet power design supports the planned load, and recommend a remedy if it does not.

Read the worked answer

Do the per-switch arithmetic first. Four APs at 25.5 W is 102 W; 20 phones at 12.9 W is 258 W; floor 1 adds roughly two cameras at 15.4 W, about 31 W. That is 360 W typical, 391 W on floor 1, and 411 W if a switch later carries two more APs - all under the 740 W budget, so the PoE allocation itself is fine. Note the hidden dependency: 740 W is only delivered with 208 V input, which is what the closet has. The real constraint is upstream. At full PoE load, seven switches would draw 7 × 740 W = 5.18 kW, plus roughly 100 W of switch electronics each, about 5.9 kW, or 6.5 kVA at 0.9 power factor, against a 30 A × 208 V = 6.24 kVA circuit. The closet is therefore marginally overloaded in the worst case even though it is comfortable today at roughly 2.9 kW actual. Remedies in order of cost: cap per-port PoE allocation and inventory the true worst case, add a second 30 A circuit before the seventh switch is installed, or split the closet. Do not size UPS runtime from nameplate PoE budgets; size it from measured draw plus the AP count you will actually deploy.

2. Diagnose the 3–5 second voice drop and describe the design change that removes it, including the Layer 2/Layer 3 boundary you would choose.

Read the worked answer

The DHCP re-run at the moment of the drop is the giveaway: each floor has its own voice VLAN and subnet, so walking from floor 3 to floor 2 is an inter-subnet roam. The client must get a new address, re-authenticate, and re-register with the call server, which is where the seconds go. Roaming within a subnet is invisible; roaming across one is not. The fix is to make the voice SSID map to a single subnet across all three floors, so every AP-to-AP move inside the building is a Layer 2 roam. Practically, that means trunking one mobility VLAN to all IDFs with a loop-free topology - a stacked or MLAG pair at the core rather than a plain redundant triangle - and anchoring it on the WLC or a mobility group. Size the subnet for the whole building: 1,100 devices is well within a /23, and you should not stretch a broadcast domain past roughly 500 active clients, so a /23 for voice plus per-floor data VLANs is the sane split. Data does not need this treatment because a data roam does not drop a call. Also enable 802.11r/k/v and confirm DHCP is reachable with low latency from every IDF, since fast roam still depends on fast address assignment.

3. Design segmentation for guest, corporate, and building IoT with the existing hardware, and state the specific controls you would configure.

Read the worked answer

Three broadcast domains with three different trust levels. Guest gets its own VLAN and its own SSID, terminated on the firewall or a DMZ anchor rather than bridged locally, with a deny to all RFC 1918 space, client-to-client blocking on the WLC, a rate limit, and the corporate DNS servers hidden behind a resolver that only answers public names. Bridging guest onto the corporate VLAN is a flat-out breach: an infected guest laptop can reach SMB on the same segment, which is precisely how the last incident spread. Corporate keeps per-floor data VLANs - no reason to stretch them - with 802.1X on the wired edge and the voice VLAN protected by a DHCP snooping and dynamic ARP inspection pair. Building IoT (cameras, badge readers, HVAC) goes on its own VLAN with no default gateway to the internet and allow-lists only to the NVR and the badge controller, because these devices ship with default credentials and no patch path. Enforce with a firewall zone pair between guest and everything, and with ACLs on the Layer 3 switch between IoT and corporate. With six switches per closet and two engineers, keep the policy count small: default deny, a handful of named permits, and log the denies so the next incident is visible in minutes.