Two Incomes, 27,400 of Card Debt, and a Second Baby
Priya and Arjun, both 34, both work full time, and have a 3-year-old son; a second child is due in eight months. Combined gross income is 148,000 USD and monthly take-home pay is 8,900. Their obligations are a mortgage payment of 2,150 on a 318,000 balance at 3.1%, credit card minimums of 640 on 27,400 at 22.9%, an auto loan of 480 on 14,200 at 6.9%, and student loans of 390 on 41,000 at 5.4%. Living costs run to 900 for groceries, 1,100 for childcare, 410 for insurance, 380 for transport, 950 discretionary and 300 miscellaneous. Cash savings total 2,300 in a high-yield account at 4.1%. Priya expects a net bonus of 6,000 in March. She will take 12 weeks of leave, 6 paid and 6 unpaid, losing about 2,900 of take-home pay, and childcare will rise to 1,850. The couple wants a 60,000 down payment within four years and has no written budget.
1. Build the household's monthly cash flow, set an emergency fund target, and rank the competing uses of the surplus.
Read the worked answer
Cash flow (current): 2,150 + 640 + 480 + 390 + 900 + 1,100 + 410 + 380 + 950 + 300 = 7,700, against take-home of 8,900, so the surplus is 1,200 a month. The stated budget is clean; the couple's sense of 'no money left' suggests leakage in the discretionary and grocery lines, which should be tracked for two months before being cut.
Essential monthly outgoings (excluding card minimums and discretionary): 2,150 + 480 + 390 + 900 + 1,100 + 410 + 380 + 300 = 6,110. A three-month fund is therefore about 18,300, and six months about 36,700. With 2,300 saved, they hold roughly 11 days of essentials - the weak point, because the card is likely the de facto emergency fund.
Ranking the uses of 1,200 a month:
- Mini-buffer to about 6,000 (roughly one month) so a car repair is not added to the card. At 1,200 a month this takes about three months.
- Credit cards at 22.9% - a guaranteed return far above the 4.1% account. The card is costing about 523 in interest a month, more than half the surplus.
- Full three-month fund, then six months.
- Down payment.
Student loans at 5.4% and the auto loan at 6.9% come after the card on rate, but the card's minimum payment is the urgent item.
2. Evaluate paying down the card against building the emergency fund, and show what should happen to the 6,000 March bonus.
Read the worked answer
The rate gap is 18.8 points (22.9% versus 4.1%), so every 1,000 left in savings while the card runs costs about 188 a year. But an all-or-nothing answer is wrong: with only 11 days of buffer and a new baby coming, clearing the card and leaving 2,300 would simply push the next emergency back onto the card, probably at a worse moment.
Recommended sequence with the numbers:
- Months 1-3: direct 1,200 a month to savings, reaching about 5,900. Pay card minimums only; do not add new charges.
- Month 4 onwards: 1,000 a month to the card (plus the 640 minimum, so 1,640 total) and 200 to savings.
- March bonus, 6,000: 4,000 to the card, 2,000 to savings (buffer about 7,900). Applying the bonus first to the card shortens the payoff by roughly three months.
Card payoff check: after the bonus, the balance is about 23,400. At 1,640 a month and 1.91% monthly interest, payoff takes about 17 months. The card is then closed to new spending or used only with an automatic full-balance payment.
Once the card is gone, redirect the 1,640 to the emergency fund: reach 18,300 in about seven months and then decide whether six months is warranted, given two incomes in the same sector and Priya's leave.
3. The second child arrives and Priya's leave begins. Quantify the change, decide what to cut, and reset the down payment goal.
Read the worked answer
Step change in the monthly position: childcare rises by 750 (1,100 to 1,850), so the 1,200 surplus falls to 450. The unpaid six weeks cost about 2,900 once, which should come from the buffer, not the card, and it temporarily removes the surplus.
A 450 surplus cannot service a card payment of 1,640, so the plan must be rebuilt before the birth, not after:
- Discretionary 950 to 500 (+450); groceries 900 to 780 via meal planning (+120); transport 380 to 320 (+60); miscellaneous 300 to 200 (+100). Total freed: 730, restoring the surplus to about 1,180 - close to today's position, and enough to keep the card payment at about 1,000 a month.
- Protect the buffer at about 8,000 through the leave; pause extra card payments for the six unpaid weeks rather than drawing on the card.
- Review the student loan: 41,000 at 5.4% is a refinance candidate once the card is cleared; do not extend the term to lower the payment while card debt survives.
Down payment reality check: 60,000 in four years needs about 1,150 a month at 4.1% on top of the card payment - it does not exist. Options are to extend to six years, reduce the target to about 40,000, or earmark later bonuses. Presenting the arithmetic is the adviser's job; allowing the couple to keep a goal that quietly depends on the card is not.