Business Sale, Cognitive Impairment, and an Ill-Timed Gift
Samuel, 62, is the sole owner of a $4.2 million manufacturing company. He wants to retire in 18 months and has received a letter of intent from a strategic buyer at 6.5x EBITDA; last year's EBITDA was $620,000. His wife, Grace, 60, has early-stage cognitive impairment and wants to stay in their $850,000 home. Their assets are $1.1 million in a 401(k), $300,000 in a Roth IRA, $450,000 in a taxable brokerage account, and the business. Liabilities include a $220,000 mortgage at 3.25%. Their estate documents are 12 years old and leave everything outright to each other, then to their two adult children equally. Samuel's brother, who has a history of creditor problems, is named as successor trustee. Samuel wants to 'sell, gift the kids $500,000, and set up a trust' before year-end. Grace's physicians expect her needs to increase; the couple has no long-term-care insurance. The buyer requires Samuel to stay on for 24 months as a consultant at $15,000 per month and wants a consulting agreement and non-compete. Samuel asks whether he should accept the letter of intent and make the gifts this year.
1. Identify the three most consequential planning tensions in this case and explain how they interact.
Read the worked answer
Three tensions: (1) liquidity and retirement timing. The letter of intent values the company at 6.5 × $620,000 = $4.03 million, but proceeds are not cash in hand until due diligence, escrow, and taxes; the 24-month consulting arrangement at $15,000 per month ($360,000) is compensation, not sale proceeds, and it may lock Samuel into the business while Grace's needs increase. (2) Grace's capacity and the estate plan. The documents leave everything outright to each other and then to the children, with Samuel's brother as successor trustee. Outright inheritance gives Grace no protective trust if Samuel dies first, and the brother's creditor history is a red flag for a fiduciary role. (3) Tax and basis. A $500,000 gift before the sale may waste the step-up in basis, trigger gift-tax reporting, and raise valuation or step-transaction issues if business interests are gifted on the eve of sale.
These interact: the sale proceeds are the funding source for Grace's care and any trust, but an ill-timed gift or poorly structured sale can reduce the amount available and create family conflict.
2. What should Samuel do before signing the letter of intent or making $500,000 of gifts? Provide a sequenced checklist with specific numbers or thresholds where possible.
Read the worked answer
Before signing or gifting: (1) Engage an M&A attorney and CPA; confirm entity structure and whether the deal is an asset or stock sale, because tax differs materially. (2) Negotiate price, escrow, working capital, earn-out, and representations; $4.03 million is a starting value, not a guarantee. (3) Review the consulting and non-compete terms: $360,000 over 24 months should be tested against retirement cash flow and separately allocated for tax; a non-compete may be ordinary income and may restrict Samuel's options. (4) Build a post-sale cash-flow and tax projection: mortgage $220,000 at 3.25%, Grace's future care costs, health insurance before Medicare, and a reserve for long-term care. (5) Do not make a $500,000 gift before the sale without modeling basis and gift tax. Cash gifts use annual exclusions, $19,000 per recipient in 2025, and lifetime exemption, but a $500,000 gift requires Form 709; gifts of business interests need a qualified appraisal and may be attacked if a sale is imminent. Consider waiting until after the sale, gifting cash, or using a trust with an independent trustee. (6) Have Grace independently evaluated for capacity and represented by separate counsel; update the estate plan, replace the brother as trustee, and add a protective trust if appropriate. (7) Confirm long-term-care insurance is likely unavailable once cognitive impairment is diagnosed; plan to self-fund.
3. Draft the client communication you would have with Samuel and Grace about the gifts, the trust, and the brother trustee. What must you say, and what must you not do?
Read the worked answer
I would meet with Samuel and Grace together, but I would also create space for Grace to speak privately. I would say: 'I am not a lawyer and I cannot draft the trust or the deed, but I can help you see the trade-offs. The $500,000 gift is not a simple year-end transaction: it may use part of your lifetime exemption, it may carry a low basis, and it may interact with the sale. Before you sign the letter of intent, you need the buyer's terms reviewed and a post-sale cash-flow projection. I am also concerned that the current estate plan leaves assets outright and names your brother as trustee; given his creditor history and Grace's health, you should discuss a protective trust and an independent trustee with an estate attorney.'
I would raise capacity gently and directly: 'Grace, I want to make sure your wishes are documented while you can participate. Would you be comfortable meeting with the attorney separately?' I must not accept a power of attorney, pressure Grace to sign, draft legal documents, value the business myself, or let Samuel make decisions for Grace without authority. I would document the conversation, provide a written summary, and ask for written authorization before sharing information with the children or the brother.