The Field Trip That Moved Twice
You are a third-year student at a Saga high school preparing for the science museum trip. In homeroom, the teacher plays a 90-second school broadcast. The broadcast says: 'Buses leave at 8:15 from the north gate. The museum opens at 9:30, so we will arrive by 9:10.' Near the end, a second announcement says: 'Because of road construction near the museum, the morning departure moves to 8:00. Students must gather at the south gate, not the north gate. The museum opening time has not changed.' After the broadcast, a classmate says, 'I heard we need lunch money.' The teacher adds, 'The museum cafe is closed today, so bring a packed lunch.' Your friend plans to arrive at the north gate at 8:10. You have a notebook and must decide what to tell your friend.
1. Your friend arrives at the north gate at 8:10. Using only the broadcast information, explain what is wrong with this plan and what the friend should do instead.
Read the worked answer
The second announcement overrides the first. The first plan, 8:15 at the north gate, is replaced by an 8:00 departure from the south gate. Arriving at the north gate at 8:10 is wrong in two ways: it is the wrong gate, and it is ten minutes after the bus has left. The friend should go to the south gate and be there before 8:00, ideally by 7:50, because the broadcast does not say the bus will wait. The museum opening time of 9:30 is unchanged, so it does not affect the gathering plan. In a listening task, the most recent explicit announcement usually controls.
2. A classmate says the trip is cancelled because of road construction. Is that supported? Explain which detail might cause the misunderstanding.
Read the worked answer
No. The broadcast ties road construction to a change in departure time and gate, not to cancellation. The phrase 'because of road construction' may make a listener infer that the whole trip is affected, but the announcement explicitly moves the departure and says the museum opening time has not changed. The lunch-money comment is also unreliable: it is hearsay from a classmate, and the teacher later says the cafe is closed. The correct judgement is to separate a schedule change from a cancellation.
3. The teacher says the museum cafe is closed. How does this affect what students should bring, and why is the classmate's lunch-money comment unreliable?
Read the worked answer
Because the cafe is closed, students need a packed lunch. Lunch money would not help if there is no open cafe. The classmate's comment is a distractor: it sounds practical but conflicts with the teacher's later, more specific information. The teacher's statement is the authoritative source in this setting, so the plan should be to bring a packed lunch and not rely on buying food. This is a typical listening judgement: a plausible detail from a peer must give way to an explicit correction from the person in charge.