Choosing a Reply at a Station Under Time Pressure
At Kofu Station, Aya, a second-year student, needs to reach Yamanashi Gakuen by 9:00 for a rehearsal. She has a paper ticket for the 8:20 local train. The station attendant says: 'The local train is running about 15 minutes late. The express is on time, but it costs 400 yen more and you must buy a separate ticket.' Aya has 1,200 yen and a heavy bag. She asks: 'Excuse me. I have a local ticket. If I take the express, will I arrive before 9:00?' The attendant replies: 'The express arrives at 8:50, but you would need to buy a ticket at the machine.' Aya's possible replies are:
A. 'Then I'll take the express. Could you show me where the ticket machine is?'
B. 'I want the local train. When does it arrive?'
C. 'The express is on time, isn't it?'
D. 'Please make the local train faster.'
1. Which reply is the most appropriate for Aya's situation? Explain using her time limit and her ticket.
Read the worked answer
Best: A. Aya must arrive by 9:00, and the express arrives at 8:50, so it solves her time problem. She has enough money for the 400-yen extra ticket, and she has already been told that a separate ticket is needed. Asking where the machine is turns the information into action.
B is not wrong in grammar, but it ignores the time risk: the local is 15 minutes late, so it may not get her there by 9:00. C repeats information the attendant has already given and does not solve anything. D is inappropriate because a passenger cannot ask station staff to make a train faster; it is not a real request in this situation. The judgement is not 'which sentence is correct English' but 'which sentence moves her toward the goal'.
2. Why does C fail even though it is grammatically correct and factually true?
Read the worked answer
C fails because it performs the wrong function. 'The express is on time, isn't it?' is a confirmation question, but the attendant has just confirmed that the express is on time. In a dialogue, repeating confirmed information wastes a turn and does not answer Aya's real problem: how to get to the school by 9:00.
A situational English question often includes a true statement that is still inappropriate because it does not respond to the previous turn. The relevant test is relevance and action, not truth value. C would be acceptable if Aya had not heard the information or wanted to double-check a surprising fact, but here it does not advance the conversation.
3. What follow-up should Aya ask about her local ticket, and why is that question necessary?
Read the worked answer
She should ask something like: 'Can I use this local ticket toward the express, or do I need to buy a completely new ticket?' This is necessary because the attendant said she 'must buy a separate ticket', but did not say whether the local ticket can be refunded, exchanged, or used as a discount.
The question protects her from paying twice without knowing her options. It also fits the situational pattern: after choosing a plan, confirm the practical condition that could cause trouble. A good answer should not assume a refund is possible; it should ask about the rule.