The borrowed minibus with a bald tyre
You are asked to drive nine passengers, including three children, from Betio to a church event in Bikenibeu in a borrowed Toyota minibus. It is 06:10 and raining lightly. Before leaving you notice: the left-front tyre has tread worn smooth on the outer edge, with a faint bulge; the spare is flat; the warrant-of-fitness sticker expired two months ago; the wipers smear; the left headlight is dim; and the brakes pull slightly right when tested at low speed. The owner says the minibus 'always does that' and that police are not out this early. The route includes two causeways and a section with potholes. Registration and insurance documents are in the glovebox, but the insurance receipt is for a different vehicle.
1. What defects make the vehicle unroadworthy for this trip, and what is your decision?
Read the worked answer
At least five defects make it unfit. The left-front tyre is worn smooth on the outer edge and has a bulge; a bulge means the internal structure is damaged, and a blowout at speed with nine passengers on a narrow causeway could put the vehicle into the water. The expired warrant of fitness means it has not been independently checked. The brakes pulling right will worsen in the wet and under load. The smeared wipers and dim headlight cut your visibility at 06:10 in rain. The insurance receipt for a different vehicle means there may be no cover for passengers or damage. You are the driver; the responsibility for the vehicle's condition is yours, not the owner's. Do not carry the passengers. Arrange a roadworthy vehicle or cancel.
2. The owner pressures you: 'Just go slowly, it's only 8 km.' How do you respond, and what practical alternatives are there?
Read the worked answer
Say no clearly and give the reason in terms the owner cannot argue with: a bulging tyre is not a 'drive slowly' defect, because a blowout does not need speed, and the brake pull will be worse with nine people on a wet causeway. The expired WOF and mismatched insurance also mean the trip could be uninsured and the vehicle could be impounded. Speed does not fix structural damage. Offer practical alternatives: call another licensed minibus operator, split the group between roadworthy cars, use the bus, or delay the trip until the tyre and brakes are fixed. If the owner insists, do not take the keys. Pressure from an owner does not transfer the risk away from you.
3. If the vehicle must be moved a short distance out of the way, what checks and limits apply?
Read the worked answer
Even a short move needs a real assessment. A bulging tyre can fail at 20 km/h, and the brakes already pull. If the vehicle is blocking a road, the safest options are to push it clear with help, call a tow, or leave it with hazard lights and warning triangles while you arrange repair. If there is genuinely no alternative and you must move it a few hundred metres, do it with no passengers, at walking pace, off the causeway, with hazard lights on, and stop immediately if the steering or braking changes. That is a recovery move, not a journey. It does not make the vehicle roadworthy or insured for carrying the church group.