Scope Creep at a Licensed Investment Adviser
Al-Noor Investment Advisory Co. holds a CMA licence limited to investment advice and arranging deals in securities. Since January 2025 it has (i) accepted discretionary mandates from eight retail clients totalling KWD 3.2 million; (ii) charged a 20% performance fee; (iii) held client securities in an omnibus account at a local bank; (iv) routed all orders through a licensed broker; and (v) advertised "target returns of 18% annually" on Instagram. Its compliance officer resigned in February and has not been replaced; the firm's capital is KWD 250,000. In April a Luxembourg UCITS manager asked Al-Noor to introduce the fund to its retail clients, saying CMA registration can be completed after subscriptions are received. Al-Noor would receive 1.5% of each subscription. The CMA has opened a routine inspection and requested the client agreements, fee schedules, and marketing materials.
1. Map each activity in Al-Noor's business to the CMA licence category it requires. Which activities exceed the firm's current licence, and what approvals must be obtained before continuing?
Read the worked answer
The analysis starts by separating advice and arranging from activities that create discretion or custody risk. Investment advice and arranging deals fall within the existing licence. Discretionary portfolio management - accepting mandates and making investment decisions without client consent for each trade - is a separate regulated activity. Managing KWD 3.2 million for eight retail clients is not a small incidental service; it requires a portfolio-management licence, adequate capital, qualified staff, and a compliant client agreement. Holding client securities in an omnibus account may also constitute custody or safekeeping, which requires a custody licence or use of an independent licensed custodian under a properly disclosed arrangement. An in-house omnibus account without custody authorisation is a structural breach, not just a documentation gap.
The 20% performance fee is not automatically prohibited, but it must be disclosed in a CMA-compliant fee schedule, agreed in writing, and calculated on a methodology that avoids rewarding excessive risk. Advertising "target returns of 18% annually" is likely misleading because it presents a projection as an expectation without a reasonable basis or prominent risk warning. The absence of a compliance officer since February is a governance breach: the firm must appoint a qualified compliance officer acceptable to the CMA and maintain an effective compliance function.
Before continuing, Al-Noor should stop the unlicensed discretionary activity, apply to vary its licence for portfolio management and any custody activity, obtain approval of revised client agreements and fee disclosures, withdraw the misleading advertising, and regularise the compliance function. Continuing while the application is pending compounds the breach.
2. Assess the Luxembourg manager's plan to market the UCITS to Al-Noor's retail clients before CMA registration, and Al-Noor's role and 1.5% subscription fee.
Read the worked answer
A home-state licence in Luxembourg does not authorise retail marketing in Kuwait. The UCITS must be registered or approved with the CMA, and a locally licensed promoter or distributor must be appointed. Al-Noor's arranging licence may allow it to introduce clients only to products that are lawfully offered in Kuwait; it does not permit it to distribute an unregistered foreign fund.
The statement that "CMA registration can be completed after subscriptions are received" reverses the regulatory sequence. Public marketing and subscription solicitation before approval would circumvent the offering rules. A narrow reverse-solicitation exception may apply where the investor approaches the manager genuinely on an unsolicited basis, but that exception cannot be manufactured by Al-Noor's active introductions and a 1.5% subscription fee. Paying a fee linked to subscriptions creates a clear financial incentive and a conflict of interest that must be disclosed and managed.
Al-Noor should decline to introduce the fund until the fund is registered, the prospectus and key investor information are approved, and a distribution agreement is in place. It should also assess whether the UCITS is suitable for retail clients, apply appropriateness or suitability checks, and disclose its remuneration. If the manager proceeds without registration, Al-Noor should not facilitate subscriptions and should consider a suspicious-activity or regulatory notification.
3. What remedial steps should Al-Noor take, and what enforcement outcomes are realistically available to the CMA?
Read the worked answer
A credible remediation plan should begin with an immediate stop of discretionary management and any custody activity that is not licensed, followed by client notification and either transfer of mandates to a licensed manager or orderly termination. Client assets must be reconciled and segregated, and an independent custodian appointed if the firm intends to continue holding assets. The firm should appoint a CMA-acceptable compliance officer, adopt written policies on fees, marketing, order handling, and conflicts, and withdraw or correct all social-media advertising. A self-report to the CMA with a timetable is usually treated more favourably than waiting for the inspection to uncover the full picture.
The CMA's enforcement toolkit under Law No. 7 of 2010 and the Executive Bylaws includes warning notices, fines, suspension or restriction of activity, appointment of a supervisor, and revocation of the licence. Because unlicensed discretionary management and custody affect retail clients, the CMA is likely to consider client harm and the firm's cooperation. Criminal referral is possible for unlicensed securities activity or misleading marketing. The realistic outcome depends on whether client money is intact, whether the firm self-reports, and whether the compliance vacancy is filled promptly. A firm that merely submits a licence application while continuing the activity should expect escalation.