The $60,000 Bond and the Vanishing Collateral
Rosa hires a bail agent to post a $60,000 surety bond for her son, who is in county jail awaiting arraignment. The agent collects $6,000 as premium, a $500 document preparation charge that appears nowhere in the signed disclosure or the insurer's filed rate, and $8,000 in cash collateral. The agent gives Rosa a handwritten note that says only collateral received and does not list the $500 charge. Forty-five days later the prosecutor dismisses the case and the court exonerates the bond. The agent returns $7,000 and keeps $1,000, telling Rosa it is a storage and monitoring fee. He also says the $6,000 premium cannot be refunded because the bond was posted. Rosa demands a full accounting. The agent's file contains no collateral ledger, no copy of the bond, and no signed fee agreement. Analyze the premium, the extra charges, the collateral, and the records the agent should have kept.
1. May the agent retain the $6,000 premium and the $500 document fee? Explain.
Read the worked answer
The $6,000 premium is 10 percent of the $60,000 bond and is earned when the bond is posted. A dismissal or early exoneration does not make the premium refundable, so the agent may generally keep the $6,000. The $500 charge is different. An extra charge must be disclosed and agreed to, and it cannot operate as a disguised premium that pushes the total consideration above the filed rate. Because the charge appears nowhere in the disclosure, the filed rate, or a signed agreement, the agent cannot unilaterally retain it. At minimum it must be refunded; if it was consideration for issuing the bond, it may also violate the filed-rate and disclosure requirements. The agent should issue an itemized correction showing the lawful premium, the disputed fee, and the refund.
2. What must happen to the $8,000 collateral and the $1,000 retention, and on what timeline?
Read the worked answer
Cash collateral is held in trust for the depositor and must be returned, with any lien released, within 30 days after the bond is exonerated, less only lawful amounts the depositor actually owes under a written agreement. The agent already returned $7,000, so the remaining $1,000 is presumed returnable. A storage and monitoring fee is not self-executing; the agent needs a disclosed, signed authorization and a reasonable basis for the charge. If no such agreement exists, the $1,000 must be returned. The agent should provide a written accounting identifying the $8,000 received, the $7,000 returned, the $1,000 retained, and the legal basis for any deduction. Retaining collateral without a lawful basis can support discipline and a civil claim.
3. What records and disclosures were missing, and what risk do they create?
Read the worked answer
The file should contain a copy of the bond or undertaking, a receipt itemizing the collateral, a fee and premium disclosure, the signed collateral agreement, and a client ledger showing trust receipts and disbursements. The handwritten note saying only collateral received is inadequate because it does not identify the amount, the depositor, or the conditions of return. Missing records make it impossible to prove the $500 fee was authorized or that the $1,000 deduction was lawful. They also create an inference of commingling or conversion if trust money cannot be traced. California bail agents are expected to keep accurate books and records, generally for at least five years, and to produce them for CDI examination. The record failures independently support licensing discipline even if the money is ultimately returned.