The Seizure, the Cataracts, and the Request to Delay
At a renewal lesson, 68-year-old Mr. Chen tells his instructor that he had a seizure five months ago, takes levetiracetam twice daily, and his doctor 'said it's fine.' His last DMV vision screening showed 20/50 in the right eye and 20/40 in the left with glasses; he has cataract surgery scheduled in two months. He wants to renew his Class C license and asks the instructor to write a letter saying he is safe to drive so he can avoid a medical review. His daughter calls separately and asks whether the school can 'delay' reporting anything until after the holidays, because the family has travel plans. Mr. Chen has been a customer for three years and has never had an accident.
1. How should the instructor handle Mr. Chen's medical and vision information?
Read the worked answer
The instructor should not assess medical fitness. A seizure five months ago and daily antiseizure medication are exactly the kind of information DMV's medical review unit evaluates; the applicable seizure-free and medication-stability criteria may or may not be met, and that is a DMV and physician decision. The vision results also need DMV evaluation: the standard involves best-corrected acuity and visual field, and 20/50 in one eye may not qualify for an unrestricted license. Cataract surgery may change the result, but until then the current vision must be assessed.
The instructor should acknowledge the information without promising confidentiality that cannot be kept, encourage Mr. Chen to report the seizure and vision change to DMV, and pause behind-the-wheel lessons until DMV clears him or the school receives a valid clearance.
2. Can the school write the requested letter or agree to delay?
Read the worked answer
The school cannot write a 'safe to drive' letter; it lacks the medical basis and would mislead DMV. It also should not delay. If the school has a policy or legal duty to report a condition that makes driving unsafe, delay could create liability and endanger the public. Even where reporting is discretionary, a knowing delay after a recent seizure and a failed vision screening is poor practice.
Tell Mr. Chen that the school cannot clear him and that the decision belongs to DMV with input from his physician. Document the information he volunteered, the referral, and the decision to pause lessons. Keep the record confidential and separate from routine training files.
3. What should the school tell the daughter, and what should be documented?
Read the worked answer
Tell the daughter the same thing without disclosing unnecessary medical details: the school cannot provide medical clearance or delay a required report. Explain that lessons are paused pending DMV review, and that this protects her father and other road users. Do not debate the family's travel plans or suggest that the timing can be managed.
Document the date and content of both conversations, who said what, the information Mr. Chen volunteered, the referral to DMV and his physician, and the pause in training. Record whether any report was made and to whom. Keep the documentation factual and objective, and avoid speculation about diagnosis or fitness. If the family later asks for a copy, follow the school's privacy policy and applicable law.