The Extension Request: Two Drafts
Maya, a first-year engineering student, missed four days of class because of a documented illness. Her final paper is due Friday at 5 p.m.; she needs three additional days. Professor Haddad's syllabus says extensions require 'a written request explaining the circumstances' but does not specify a format. Maya drafts two versions. Draft A: 'Hey Prof, I'm totally swamped and can't finish by Friday. Can I get a few more days? Thx.' Draft B: 'Respected Professor Haddad, I humbly beseech Your Excellency to look with mercy upon my request for an extension, as I am utterly unworthy of your consideration.' A friend tells her Draft A is fine because 'professors are busy and prefer short emails.' Another friend says Draft B is safer because 'formal language shows respect.' Maya has not yet attached the medical note. She has one day before the deadline.
1. Diagnose the register problems in Draft A and Draft B. Which is more likely to succeed, and why?
Read the worked answer
Draft A fails on audience and purpose: 'Hey Prof,' 'totally swamped,' and 'Thx' read as casual and vague, and it never states the request precisely (how many days?) or mentions the documented illness or the syllabus requirement. It treats a formal request as a text message. Draft B overcorrects: 'humbly beseech,' 'Your Excellency,' and 'utterly unworthy' are servile and archaic, and they obscure the practical information. Overformality can read as parody or as an attempt to manipulate. Neither draft is clearly better; both misjudge the relationship. The successful register is polite, direct, specific, and brief: a clear subject line, one sentence of circumstance, one precise request, and an offer to provide documentation. That is what the syllabus asks for and what a busy professor can act on.
2. Write a revised email of no more than 90 words. Explain two choices you made.
Read the worked answer
Subject: Extension request, final paper. Dear Professor Haddad, I am writing to request a three-day extension on the final paper, due Friday at 5 p.m. I was ill for four days this week and have a medical note I can attach. I have completed the reading and a draft and would use the time to revise. I understand if you cannot grant this and am happy to provide documentation or discuss alternatives. Thank you, Maya. Choices: (1) I named the exact extension length and deadline, because 'a few more days' forces the professor to negotiate; (2) I mentioned the medical note without attaching it on first contact, because the syllabus requires a written explanation and the note supports it without cluttering the message.
3. A friend says formal language always shows respect. Evaluate that claim.
Read the worked answer
Formality is a tool, not a measure of respect. Respect in academic email is shown by addressing the person correctly, being specific, not wasting their time, and acknowledging their discretion. Draft B's 'Your Excellency' is not more respectful; it is a register mismatch that can seem mocking or manipulative. Draft A's casualness can seem disrespectful because it ignores the professor's stated process. The relevant judgment is fit: match the formality to the relationship and the stakes, and keep the content precise. In most university settings, plain standard English with a polite opener and a clear request is the safest choice.