Night Navigation: Injury, Panic and a Weak Radio
You are the section commander of eight officer cadets on a night navigation exercise. At 01:20 your section is 900 metres from checkpoint 4, which must be reached by 02:00. One cadet has turned an ankle and can walk slowly with support but cannot carry a full pack. A second cadet is breathing rapidly, says he cannot see properly, and is starting to argue with the navigator. The map has become wet and the ink has run on the route trace. The radio battery indicator shows low, and the last contact with base was 25 minutes ago. Visibility is about 30 metres in mist. You have one first-aid kit, two torches with weak batteries, and no vehicle access within 1.5 km. The exercise rules require a minimum of two cadets together at all times and a situation report to base if the section is delayed by more than 20 minutes.
1. State your immediate priorities in order and justify the order.
Read the worked answer
First, stop and secure the group: halt in a safe, dry spot, take a headcount, and keep the section together. Moving while a cadet is panicking and the map is unreadable multiplies risk. Second, treat and assess the ankle: check circulation, sensation and movement, elevate and support the joint, and redistribute the injured cadet's pack to two others. Third, calm the panicking cadet: speak slowly, reduce stimulation, have him sit, and give him one simple task such as holding a torch. Fourth, restore navigation and communications: protect the map, use compass bearing and known features, and send a concise radio report while the battery lasts. Mission achievement comes after safety and communication. The checkpoint deadline is a planning constraint, not a reason to push an injured and panicking group through mist. A commander who treats the 02:00 deadline as the first priority is choosing the mission over the people, which is the wrong order under the exercise rules.
2. The injured cadet cannot reach checkpoint 4 by 02:00 without risking further injury. What do you do, and how do you keep to the two-cadet rule?
Read the worked answer
I would not split the section into a single helper and the main body. I would move the whole section to the nearest safe, identifiable point, then send a two-cadet team back along the reverse bearing to the last known point or to meet the safety vehicle, while the remainder stays together at the RV. The two-cadet team carries a torch, the radio if reception is better there, and a written note of the situation. The injured cadet stays with at least two others, not alone. If no safe pair can be spared, the correct choice is to stop the whole section, make camp or shelter, and report by radio; missing a checkpoint is an exercise failure, not a safety failure. The answer should show that the two-cadet rule is a floor, not a target, and that the commander must nominate an RV, a return time, and a fallback action if the pair does not return.
3. Draft the situation report you would send to base, and explain what you would leave out.
Read the worked answer
A concise report: 'Base, this is Section 3. Location: 900 metres south-west of checkpoint 4, grid reference to follow. One cadet ankle injury, walking slowly with support; one cadet suffering suspected panic attack, conscious and breathing. Map damaged, mist, visibility 30 metres. Section halted, casualty treated, not proceeding to checkpoint 4 at this time. Request safety vehicle to nearest track access and confirmation of RV. Radio battery low; next contact in 15 minutes. Over.'
I would leave out speculation about whether the cadet 'broke' his ankle, blame about the wet map, and long descriptions of the route. The report should give who, where, what, what you are doing, what you need, and when you will call again. Naming the suspected panic attack is useful because it affects the medical response, but it should be described as observed behaviour, not a diagnosis. The report should end with a clear request, not an apology. If the radio fails, the written note and the pre-briefed RV become the fallback.