Medical Screening Before the Fitness Assessment
A candidate for officer cadet training, aged 18, attends the pre-training medical screening. Findings: height 1.72 m; weight 85.8 kg; BMI 29.0; resting heart rate 92 beats per minute on the first reading; repeat after 10 minutes of sitting quietly, 84 beats per minute; blood pressure 128/78; mild wheeze after a 1.6 km run, relieved within a few minutes by rest; no inhaler currently prescribed; old ankle fracture two years ago, fully healed, no pain or swelling, full range of movement; no other symptoms. The screening policy states: BMI above 27 requires medical officer review; a resting heart rate above 90 on the first reading is repeated after 10 minutes, and if below 90 the candidate is cleared on that item; exertional wheeze requires spirometry and medical officer review before clearance; a fracture more than 12 months old with no symptoms is cleared subject to a functional test.
1. Apply the screening policy to each finding and state the candidate's current fitness status.
Read the worked answer
BMI: 29.0 is above 27, so medical officer review is required; BMI alone does not disqualify. Resting heart rate: the first reading of 92 is above 90, so the policy requires a repeat. The repeat is 84, which is below 90, so this item is cleared. Blood pressure: 128/78 is within the stated screening range, so no action on the policy as given. Exertional wheeze: this triggers spirometry and medical officer review before clearance; it cannot be cleared by observation alone. Old ankle fracture: it is more than 12 months old, asymptomatic, with full movement, so it is cleared subject to a functional test. The correct status is not yet cleared - temporarily deferred for spirometry and medical officer review. The candidate should not be labelled permanently unfit. The ankle finding is the easiest to misread: a healed fracture is not an automatic bar, but the functional test still has to be recorded.
2. What additional steps would you take, in what order, and what would you record?
Read the worked answer
Order: first, complete the administrative screen and record the repeat heart rate and the time interval, because that item is already resolved. Second, arrange spirometry and a medical officer review for the exertional wheeze before any clearance is issued. Third, complete the functional ankle test - for example, a supervised run, hop and change-of-direction test - and record pain, swelling and symmetry. Fourth, give advice on heat and hydration, since the screening does not mention heat tolerance but the training environment may. Record the raw observations, the policy criterion triggered by each, the repeat measurement, the review outcome, and the functional test result. Record that the wheeze was observed after exertion and relieved by rest, exactly as reported, not 'asthma'. The record should also state the candidate's current status as deferred, not fit and not permanently unfit, and who must sign the final clearance.
3. The candidate asks whether he can start training next week 'because the ankle is fine'. How should you answer, and what risk would be created by clearing him now?
Read the worked answer
Answer: the ankle is not the blocker. The ankle finding is provisionally cleared subject to a functional test, but the exertional wheeze is unresolved and the policy requires spirometry and medical officer review first. Starting next week would bypass that review. The risk is not only a possible missed diagnosis; it is that an undiagnosed or poorly controlled exercise-related breathing problem may appear during a demanding session, at a distance from the medical bay, and be mistaken for poor fitness. That creates a safety risk for the candidate and a supervision risk for the staff. The correct answer is to explain the specific outstanding item, give the expected timeline for spirometry and review, and offer a provisional start date conditional on clearance. Do not tell the candidate he is 'unfit'; tell him he is temporarily deferred on one item. That is accurate, fair, and actionable.