Mortgage valuation with a second purpose and a value floor
A licensed valuer receives instructions from a Colombo-based bank to value a 12-year-old, eight-storey office building in Colombo 03 for mortgage security. The credit officer also asks that the report be suitable for the bank's annual financial statements and that the valuer 'keep the value at no less than LKR 1.2 billion' because the branch is close to its lending limit. The building is 60% leased to one tenant whose lease expires in 18 months; market rents in the area have fallen 8% over the past year. There is an unregistered rooftop restaurant, a pending property-tax assessment, and no rental evidence for the rooftop. The bank wants the report in five working days. The valuer has good comparable sales evidence but only limited lease evidence. The client asks the valuer to omit any 'material uncertainty' paragraph and to state 'market value' without defining it.
1. Identify the standards and professional issues raised by the instruction and explain how the valuer should respond to the two client requests.
Read the worked answer
Issues. The instruction contains two improper requests. A valuation is an opinion derived from evidence; agreeing a floor of LKR 1.2 billion reverses the process and creates self-interest and advocacy threats. Omitting a material uncertainty paragraph would make the report misleading if uncertainty exists; if there is no material uncertainty, the valuer can say so, but cannot pre-commit to silence. Response. Explain politely that the value will be reported as found; if the bank requires a minimum value for credit purposes, that is a lending decision, not a valuation instruction. State that material uncertainty must be disclosed under IVS 2022 when the evidence is insufficient, and that 'market value' will be defined. Offer an early conference call and a scope letter. If the client insists, decline or withdraw. Also flag the dual-purpose request: a mortgage valuation and a financial-reporting valuation may require different bases and scopes.
2. Explain the basis of value and scope of work for a dual-purpose instruction, and whether one report can serve both mortgage and financial reporting.
Read the worked answer
Basis. For mortgage security, the usual basis is market value, often with a forced-sale or mortgage-lending-value commentary if the bank asks. For financial reporting, the basis is fair value under SLFRS 13, which is an exit price in an orderly transaction between market participants. These can coincide, but not automatically. Scope. The scope must identify the property, the interest valued, the purpose, the basis, the valuation date, inspection, information relied on, assumptions, and reporting. The lease expiring in 18 months, the 8% rent fall, the unregistered rooftop restaurant, and the pending tax assessment are all scope items. One report? One report can serve both only if the definitions and assumptions are compatible and both user groups are identified. Otherwise provide separate sections or separate reports; do not blur bases. The valuer should confirm that the bank's credit department understands that a valuation is not a guarantee of realisable value.
3. List the disclosures and caveats you would include and explain why they are necessary.
Read the worked answer
Disclosures. Include: (i) basis of value and definition; (ii) interest valued and title/planning status; (iii) inspection date and extent; (iv) sources and reliance; (v) assumption about the unregistered rooftop restaurant and the pending tax liability; (vi) lease expiry and re-letting risk; (vii) material uncertainty if comparable or rental evidence is thin; (viii) restriction on reliance by third parties; (ix) fee basis and independence; (x) valuation date. Why. These let the reader see what was and was not tested. The rooftop and tax issues could change net income; the short lease affects capitalisation; thin rental evidence affects confidence. Disclosures do not replace evidence, but they prevent the report from being read as more certain than it is. The valuer should also keep a file note of the client's requests and the refusal.