Coordinating Group LTD With an Individual Own-Occupation Policy
Marco, 46, is the 100% owner-employee of an S corporation architectural firm. He pays himself a $120,000 W-2 salary and takes roughly $60,000 more as pass-through profit. The firm's group long-term disability plan pays 60% of base salary to a $6,000 monthly maximum, has a 90-day elimination period, and defines disability as own-occupation for only 24 months before switching to any-occupation. The S corporation pays the group premium and does not include it in Marco's W-2. Marco performs site visits and hand-draws concept sketches; a hand or wrist injury is his biggest fear. He wants an individual disability policy and asks whether the S corporation should pay those premiums too. The firm also carries a small business overhead expense policy and funds Marco's HSA through the corporation.
1. Quantify the gap between what the group plan actually delivers and Marco's income need, then outline the design features the individual policy must have.
Read the worked answer
Start with what the group plan actually delivers. Sixty percent of $120,000 is $72,000 a year, or $6,000 a month, which happens to equal the plan maximum - but because the S corporation pays the premium and does not report it as wages, every dollar of that benefit is taxable. At a combined marginal rate near 35%, Marco nets roughly $3,900 a month, far below what a $180,000 earner needs to cover a mortgage and two children in college.
Individual carriers typically cap total disability coverage near 60-70% of gross income, and most count the group benefit when calculating the issue limit. On $180,000 of income the ceiling is roughly $9,000-$10,500 a month; netting out the $6,000 group benefit leaves room for perhaps $3,000-$4,500 of individual coverage. Request the carrier's written benefit-offset analysis rather than guessing.
Design priorities: a true own-occupation definition with no 24-month switch - essential for someone whose hands are the business; residual or partial disability benefits; a future increase option so coverage grows with income without new underwriting; and a cost-of-living rider. Match the 90-day elimination period to the group plan to avoid an income gap; a 180-day period would leave three months with no benefit at all.
2. Marco asks whether the S corporation should pay the individual disability premiums. Explain the tax consequences of each funding method and recommend one.
Read the worked answer
Two structures, and the choice is mostly about who bears the tax.
Corporation pays, nothing on the W-2: the corporation deducts the premium, but benefits become taxable income to Marco when he is disabled. That is the same trap the group plan already creates.
Marco pays personally: no deduction, but every benefit dollar is received income tax free. For a policy costing perhaps $3,000-$4,000 a year against a potential $50,000 annual benefit, paying personally is almost always the better trade.
Corporation pays and includes the premium in Marco's W-2 wages: the corporation deducts the payment, Marco's basis in the policy increases, and benefits are received tax free. Net cost is roughly the same as personal payment, but the deduction stays inside the business. Because Marco owns more than 2% of the S corporation, the mechanics must run through payroll - the self-employed health insurance deduction does not extend to disability premiums.
Recommendation: the W-2 route for the individual policy, with the corporation paying the group premium and reporting that premium as wages as well. Whichever route is used, document it in the corporate minutes and apply it consistently; retroactive recharacterization at claim time is expensive.
3. Explain how the business overhead expense policy fits with the individual policy, including its tax treatment and appropriate benefit period. Add what should be considered regarding the corporation-funded HSA.
Read the worked answer
The overhead expense policy covers the practice, not Marco: rent, staff salaries, utilities, malpractice premiums, and similar fixed costs. It does not replace personal income, and it should be paired with the individual DI policy so the firm stays solvent while Marco recovers and his household bills are paid from the DI benefit.
Tax treatment runs opposite to individual DI: premiums are deductible by the S corporation as an ordinary business expense, and benefits are taxable when received. That is acceptable because they replace deductible business expenses. Watch the benefit period - 12 months is often too short for a serious hand injury; 18-24 months is common. Confirm that the policy pays in addition to, not in lieu of, the DI benefit, and that the covered expenses are listed specifically.
On the HSA: contributions made by the S corporation for a more-than-2% shareholder must be reported on Marco's W-2 and deducted by him, not booked as a corporate expense line. Contributions must stop once he enrolls in Medicare, and HSA funds cannot pay individual disability premiums. Keep the HSA fully funded as a separate medical reserve; it complements but does not replace disability coverage.