Disability Income Gap for a Solo Dentist
Dr. Patel, 44, is a solo dentist with $260,000 of net income. Her employer-paid group long-term disability plan pays 60% of the first $120,000 of income, capped at $6,000 per month. Benefits are taxable because the employer pays the premium. The elimination period is 90 days, the definition changes to any occupation after 24 months, and benefits are offset by Social Security. She has had two episodes of low back pain treated with physical therapy, no surgery, and is currently asymptomatic. An individual disability policy is available with an $8,500 monthly benefit, a 60-day elimination period, own-occupation coverage to age 65, residual disability, a cost-of-living rider, and a future increase option. The annual premium is $6,200. Her practice overhead is $35,000 per month, including lease and staff costs that continue if she is disabled. She asks whether to replace the group plan or supplement it.
1. Calculate the after-tax income replacement from the group plan and the practical gap. Assume a 32% marginal tax rate and $260,000 of net income.
Read the worked answer
The group plan pays 60% of the first $120,000, or $72,000 per year, which equals $6,000 per month. Because the employer pays the premium, the benefit is taxable. At a 32% marginal rate, the after-tax benefit is about $72,000 x 0.68 = $48,960 per year, or $4,080 per month.
Her after-tax working income is roughly $260,000 x 0.68 = $176,800. A 70% replacement target would be about $123,760 after tax, leaving a gap of about $74,800 per year, or $6,233 per month. An individual benefit of $8,500 per month paid with after-tax dollars would be tax-free and would produce combined after-tax income of about $150,960, or roughly 85% of after-tax working income. That may be more than needed for personal income, but the group definition changes to any occupation after 24 months and is offset by Social Security. The individual policy is filling both a dollar gap and a definitional gap. The analysis should also recognize that the group benefit may stop if she can work in another occupation, while the individual own-occupation benefit continues.
2. Recommend a disability coverage structure, including individual benefit amount, elimination period, definition, riders, and business overhead coverage. Explain the tradeoffs.
Read the worked answer
A reasonable structure is to keep the group plan as the base and add an individual policy with a $6,000 to $6,500 monthly benefit, a 90-day elimination period, own-occupation to age 65, residual disability, a cost-of-living rider, and a future increase option. Choosing $6,000 rather than $8,500 controls premium and avoids overinsurance, while still bringing total after-tax replacement close to the 70% target. A 90-day elimination period aligns with the group plan and reduces premium; she should confirm she has cash to cover the 90 days.
Own-occupation is the key feature because the group plan becomes any-occupation after 24 months. Residual disability protects against a partial loss of income, which is common for a dentist with back problems. The future increase option lets her raise coverage as income grows without new medical evidence, subject to financial underwriting. A business overhead policy of about $10,000 to $15,000 per month for 12 to 18 months should be considered because rent, staff, and utilities continue. Overhead coverage is not a substitute for personal disability income; it reimburses eligible practice expenses.
The tradeoff is premium: adding COLA, residual, and a future increase option raises cost, but dropping own-occupation or buying too little benefit undermines the purpose. The group plan should not be cancelled, because the employer pays it and it provides a base benefit.
3. What underwriting and tax steps should be taken before replacing or supplementing the group plan?
Read the worked answer
Underwriting first: disclose the back history fully, including dates, physical therapy, any imaging, and current symptoms. The carrier may issue a back exclusion rider, a higher premium, or a modified offer. Apply to more than one carrier through informal inquiry before submitting a formal application. Do not cancel the group plan until the individual policy is issued and in force. Use the future increase option to add coverage later if the back issue limits the initial benefit.
Tax treatment should be coordinated deliberately. The group benefit is taxable because the employer pays the premium. If Dr. Patel pays the individual premium personally with after-tax dollars, the individual benefits are tax-free. If the practice pays the premium, the benefits become taxable and the after-tax gap widens. The practice may still deduct the premium, but the personal after-tax result is usually better when the insured pays. Document the premium payment source and keep personal and business funds separate.
Also review the group plan's Social Security offset and any rehabilitation or return-to-work provisions. The individual policy should be coordinated so that total benefits do not exceed the carrier's issue limits, and the client should understand that individual benefits are not reduced by the group plan unless the policy says so.