'I've Walked to Breakfast for 60 Years'
Mr. Brennan is 68, has mild cognitive impairment and Parkinson's disease, and uses a rolling walker. His care plan says 'one-person assist with ambulation.' Twice this week he has gotten up alone; last night staff found him sitting on the floor in his room, uninjured but unable to say how he got there. This morning he says, 'I've walked to breakfast by myself for 60 years and I'm not stopping now,' and stands up. You are the only CNA on the hall with 10 residents; the dining room is 40 feet away; the nurse is in the medication room 30 feet down the hall.
1. He is already standing. What do you do in the next 60 seconds?
Read the worked answer
Do not push him back into the chair, grab his arm, or block him with your body. A struggle with a man who has Parkinson's and poor balance is how a fall happens.
- Step to his side, offer the walker with a hand on the frame, and say: 'I'll walk with you. Let's go.' Walking beside him is the one-person assist on his care plan, so he keeps the independence and you keep the safety.
- Angle yourself on his weaker side and stay close enough to steady him, without holding him unless he begins to fall.
- Call out to the nurse or use your radio/call light as you go. You cannot leave him to find help.
- Watch for Parkinson's problems mid-walk: freezing at doorways, shuffling, or a sudden drop in blood pressure on standing. If he freezes, do not pull him; stop, let him reset, and cue him to step.
- At the table, get him seated before you leave him.
2. Was it wrong to tell him no? Explain where safety ends and his rights begin.
Read the worked answer
Telling him the rule as a flat 'no' was not the best tool, though the concern behind it was legitimate.
- He has mild cognitive impairment, not an incapacity finding. He retains the right to make choices, including risky ones, and the right to be the least-restricted option.
- A care plan is a professional judgment, not a court order. It can be wrong, and it can be outdated, especially after two unsupervised trips and one unwitnessed floor episode.
- The CNA's job is not to enforce the plan by force. It is to provide the safest version of what he wants, report the gap between plan and reality, and advocate for a review.
- What is not acceptable: locking his walker away, using a lap belt or chair alarm as punishment, or threatening him so he stops asking.
Ask the nurse for a therapy and fall-risk review, and a care-plan meeting that includes him.
3. What if he refuses your help and walks off alone anyway?
Read the worked answer
Stay with him anyway. Supervision without touching him is not restraint; it is the least restrictive safe response.
- Walk a step behind and to the side, keep talking normally, and do not announce to the room that he is 'wandering.'
- Let him do the walking. Intervene physically only to break a fall, and lower him to the floor rather than catching him fully.
- Radio or call for the nurse if he heads somewhere unsafe, such as stairs or the front door.
Afterward, report and document the facts: 'At 0745 resident stood and stated he would walk to breakfast alone. CNA ambulated beside him at his request/against his stated preference. No loss of balance. Nurse notified.' Then ask that his refusal of assistance be reviewed while you are still on shift, because a pattern of unsupervised walking needs a plan, not just a note.