Delegation to an Unlicensed Optical Technician
Dr. Franco owns a Massachusetts optical practice and employs Kyle, an unlicensed optical technician with no formal optometric training. On days Dr. Franco works at a second office, Kyle performs non-contact tonometry, autorefraction, and lensometry; he also tells a 52-year-old patient with burning eyes that she has 'dry eye' and should use preservative-free artificial tears four times daily. On one occasion Kyle adjusts a patient's soft contact lens power by 0.50 D because the patient says the vision is 'a little soft,' then orders a new box of lenses. Dr. Franco reviews the charts remotely by video call at the end of the week. A patient complains to the Board that she never saw the doctor and that the technician diagnosed her. Dr. Franco says Kyle is 'just doing technical work' and that all charts are co-signed.
1. Which of Kyle's activities may be delegated, and which may not?
Read the worked answer
Issue: Which tasks may an unlicensed optical technician perform in a Massachusetts optometric practice?
Rule: Unlicensed assistants may perform delegated, non-invasive technical tasks under appropriate supervision. They may not perform optometry: refraction, contact lens fitting or evaluation, diagnosis, or prescribing. The licensee remains responsible for the acts and must not aid unlicensed practice.
Application: Non-contact tonometry, autorefraction, and lensometry are technical tasks. Telling the patient she has dry eye and directing treatment is diagnosis and prescribing. Adjusting contact lens power and ordering lenses is contact lens practice. Those acts are not technical support.
Conclusion: Kyle may perform the testing tasks only under proper supervision, but he may not diagnose dry eye, recommend a treatment plan as a diagnosis, change a contact lens power, or order lenses. Dr. Franco must personally perform refractions, contact lens evaluations, and diagnoses. The dry-eye advice and lens change must be reviewed and corrected with the patient.
2. What level of supervision does Massachusetts require for delegated tasks, and was it met?
Read the worked answer
Delegated technical tasks require appropriate supervision by the licensee, with the level depending on the task and the patient. Remote weekly video review is not direct supervision for testing performed while Dr. Franco is at another office. Co-signing a chart after the fact does not supply the missing supervision, especially when the technician is making judgments. The practice should have written protocols identifying which tasks may be delegated, who is trained, and when the doctor must be on site. Patients should know who is providing care. Dr. Franco's arrangement allowed an untrained technician to operate with de facto independence. That is inadequate supervision and supports a Board finding that he aided unlicensed practice.
3. What is Dr. Franco's liability, and what should the practice do now?
Read the worked answer
Dr. Franco is responsible for the delegated acts and for the practice environment. The Board can discipline him for aiding unlicensed practice, inadequate supervision, and failing to ensure that diagnosis and contact lens care were performed by a licensee. The practice should immediately restrict Kyle to defined technical duties, require on-site supervision, and stop remote sign-off as a substitute. It should review the affected patients' records, correct the contact lens order, and arrange appropriate evaluations. It should document training and written protocols. In responding to the Board, Dr. Franco should acknowledge the supervision failure rather than claim that co-signing makes the acts lawful. Remediation is mitigating; continued delegation after notice would be aggravating.