Is the Snow Really a Blanket?
During a poetry lesson, students read this four-line poem: 'The snow is a blanket, / Soft and white. / It covers the grass / All through the night.' A student says, 'The poem says snow is a blanket, so that is a fact. Snow really does cover grass.' Another student says, 'No, snow is not a blanket, so the poem is wrong.' The teacher wants students to understand that poets use comparisons to help readers picture and feel something, and that a comparison can be true in a figurative way without being literally true. The class has discussed similes and metaphors but still confuses figurative language with factual statements. The teacher plans to ask students to explain what the comparison helps them see, not just name it. The teacher also wants students to use words from the poem as evidence for their interpretations.
1. How should the teacher respond to both students? Explain what the comparison 'The snow is a blanket' does and why it is not a factual claim that snow is literally a blanket.
Read the worked answer
The teacher should show that both students are treating the comparison as a literal fact. The first student is right that snow covers grass, but the poem does not say snow is a real blanket. The second student is right that snow is not literally a blanket, but that does not make the poem wrong. The comparison works because snow and a blanket share qualities: both are soft, both are white or pale, and both cover something. The poem gives evidence for those shared qualities in the words 'Soft and white' and 'It covers the grass.' A metaphor says one thing is another to help the reader notice those qualities. The teacher can say: 'The poem is not telling us what snow is made of. It is helping us picture how snow covers the grass.' That keeps the factual question separate from the figurative comparison.
2. What question could the teacher ask to help students move from labeling the comparison to interpreting it? Give one question and explain what it would reveal.
Read the worked answer
A useful question is: 'What does calling the snow a blanket help you see or feel about the snow?' This question moves students away from asking whether the sentence is literally true and toward what the comparison does. Students might say it makes the snow seem soft, quiet, or protective, or that it makes the grass seem tucked in for the night. They would need to point to words such as 'Soft and white' or 'All through the night' to support that interpretation. The question also shows that a metaphor can create a feeling or picture without being a fact. A follow-up could be: 'Which words in the poem make the blanket comparison work?' That keeps the focus on evidence rather than on naming the device.