The 15-Year-Old's Disclosure
Marcus, an LCPC at a Baltimore County nonprofit, has seen Tia, age 15, for six sessions for panic attacks and school refusal. Tia's parents are divorced but share legal custody; her mother consented to treatment, and her father emails weekly asking for progress notes. In session, Tia discloses that her 22-year-old cousin 'had sex with me' three months ago at a family gathering. She says she told no one else, begs Marcus not to tell, and threatens to stop therapy if he does. Tia's mother later calls and says, 'If Tia told you something about family, we handle it at home-don't report anything.' Marcus has no prior suspicion of abuse and no safety concerns about Tia's immediate home. He has a supervision appointment in two days.
1. Does Marcus have a mandatory reporting duty? To whom, when, and what must he disclose?
Read the worked answer
Yes. A disclosure by a 15-year-old that a 22-year-old cousin had sex with her is a reportable suspicion of child sexual abuse. Marcus is a mandated reporter as a licensed counselor. He must report to the local department of social services/child protective services or to law enforcement, as Maryland law permits, and he must do so promptly-he cannot wait two days for supervision and cannot defer to the mother's instruction. The mother's preference does not override the statutory duty.
Marcus should report the facts he knows: Tia's age, the cousin's age and relationship, the approximate date and location, Tia's statements, and any immediate safety concerns. He should not investigate, interview the cousin, or promise confidentiality. He should tell Tia, in a developmentally appropriate way and before reporting when possible, that he must make a report, what information he will share, and what may happen next. He should document the disclosure, the report, the agency contacted, the time, and any safety planning. If Tia's immediate safety is at risk, he should also take protective steps.
2. How should Marcus handle Tia's plea for secrecy and her mother's demand that he not report?
Read the worked answer
Marcus should acknowledge Tia's fear and explain that confidentiality has limits he cannot negotiate. He should not have promised absolute secrecy; if he did, he must correct that now. The therapeutic task is to preserve the alliance while being honest: 'I have to report this because the law requires it and because I am concerned about your safety. I will tell you what I am doing.' He should ask what Tia fears will happen and address those fears within his role, without promising outcomes.
With the mother, Marcus should be clear that he is not asking permission to report and that the report is required. He should avoid disclosing more clinical detail than necessary. He should document the mother's request, his explanation, and Tia's response. Reporting does not end treatment; Marcus should plan follow-up, monitor Tia's safety, and consult his supervisor immediately rather than waiting for the scheduled appointment. If the family becomes retaliatory or Tia's safety deteriorates, he should escalate.
3. What should Marcus do about the father's request for progress notes and the recordkeeping around this disclosure?
Read the worked answer
The father shares legal custody, so he may have rights to the minor's records, but that does not mean Marcus should automatically release full process notes. Marcus should review the custody order, agency policy, and Board guidance; release only information he is legally required to provide; and prefer a treatment summary over raw process notes when appropriate. He should discuss with Tia what information may be shared and why, while recognizing that a parent's legal rights may limit her control over the record.
The record should include the disclosure in Tia's own words, the mandated report, the agency and time contacted, the mother's call, the father's request, the information released or withheld and the legal basis, the safety assessment, and the supervision consultation. Marcus should not alter earlier notes or omit the disclosure to protect the family. Good documentation protects Tia, supports continuity, and demonstrates that Marcus followed the reporting law and record-release rules.