Suspicious Driving Log Before a Road Test
A 16-year-old Segment 2 student submits a driving log with 52 supervised hours and 12 night hours. The parent signed it, but the dates show 8 hours on a single Saturday and 6 hours on a school day when the teen had an away game. Two entries are in different handwriting. The teen admits his older brother “helped fill in” some hours and says the total is “basically right.” The road test is in five days, and the parent calls to say the instructor should sign because the teen is a good driver. The instructor’s Segment 2 class completed yesterday; the certificate is the last step. The instructor must decide whether to certify, what to do about the log, and how to protect the integrity of the program.
1. Can the instructor sign the Segment 2 certificate based on this log? Explain the reasoning and the risks.
Read the worked answer
No. The certificate confirms that the student completed Segment 2 and that the supporting record is credible. This log is not credible: 8 hours in one day and 6 hours on a day the teen was at an away game are implausible, and the mixed handwriting plus the brother’s involvement show the entries were not reliably made by the supervising parent. Even if the totals of 52 hours and 12 night hours would otherwise exceed the 50/10 road-test threshold, the instructor cannot certify numbers that appear fabricated or estimated. Signing would misrepresent the record, expose the instructor and school to liability, and undermine the program’s integrity. The instructor should not certify until a parent or guardian provides a corrected, dated, and attested log, and the student may need to accumulate additional documented hours.
2. What steps should the instructor take with the family and the record, and what happens to the road test?
Read the worked answer
The instructor should meet with the parent and teen, explain the specific discrepancies, and ask for a corrected log with dates, actual driving times, and a parent’s signature attesting to accuracy. The instructor should document the conversation and keep the original log rather than destroying it. The instructor should avoid making a fraud accusation without evidence, but should clearly state that the current log cannot be accepted. The road test should be postponed until the record is valid. If the family cannot produce a credible log, the student must drive more supervised hours and document them prospectively. If program policy requires reporting suspected falsification, the instructor should follow that policy. Being a “good driver” does not replace the documented GDL requirements.