The Chair-Renter and the Bad Review
You rent a chair for $250 a week at a salon. The owner sets the service menu prices, requires you to work Tuesday through Saturday, 10 to 7, supplies all product, sends you the salon's walk-ins, requires a uniform and attendance at monthly staff meetings, and takes 30% of your retail sales. Last week a client no-showed a $65 gel set, and you want to charge her card on file - you never told her you would. She then left a one-star review saying you 'ruined her nails and refused to fix them,' which is not what happened. The owner tells you to reply publicly with the details and to 'remind her what she signed.'
1. Based on these facts, is your arrangement more likely employee or independent contractor, and why does it matter?
Read the worked answer
Walk through the control factors rather than the label. The owner controls your schedule (set days and hours), your prices, your uniform, your attendance at meetings, your product supply, and your client flow by sending walk-ins - that is a high degree of behavioral and financial control, which points toward employee status even though you pay 'rent.' A true booth renter typically sets their own hours and prices, buys their own supplies, and controls their own clientele. Collecting rent and a percentage of retail on top of that control makes the arrangement look even less like a clean rental.
It matters because misclassification affects payroll taxes, unemployment and workers' compensation coverage, wage-and-hour rules, and who carries liability. It also affects you practically: if you are an employee, the no-show policy and the review response are the owner's call, not yours alone. Get advice from a qualified professional rather than assuming the contract's wording decides it.
2. Can you charge the no-show's card? What should the policy have looked like?
Read the worked answer
Not after the fact. Charging a card for a fee the client never agreed to is a dispute you will lose and a chargeback you deserve to lose. A card on file is only a tool for enforcing a disclosed policy - it is not itself permission.
A defensible policy is written, given before the appointment (on the booking page, confirmation text, and intake form), signed or electronically accepted, and applied consistently to all clients, including the owner's friends. It states the amount, the notice window, and what happens for late arrival versus no-show, and it complies with card-network rules for storing and charging cards. Going forward, decide the policy with whoever actually controls pricing - based on the facts above, that is likely the owner - and put it in place for the next booking, not retroactively for this one.
3. How should the public review be answered?
Read the worked answer
Answer briefly, calmly, and without disclosing anything about her service, her card, or her no-show. Confidentiality does not stop applying because she posted first, and a public fight reads badly to every future client who sees it. Do not repeat the owner's suggestion to 'remind her what she signed' - that escalates and exposes details you should not share.
A workable reply: acknowledge she was unhappy, state that client care matters to the salon, invite her to contact you directly to discuss, and stop there. One or two sentences. Then handle the substance privately - if a redo is warranted under your policy, offer it; if not, say so once and move on.
Also separate the two issues: the fee dispute and the public review are different problems. Settle the fee question through the correct channel (the owner, if you are an employee) and do not let it leak into the public response.