The Broken Heater Email
You are writing a 120–150-word email to the manager of your apartment building, Ms. Reyes, about a broken heater. The temperature in your unit has been below 60°F for four nights, and you have a documented asthma condition. You have already called the emergency line twice: on Monday at 9 p.m. and Tuesday at 7 a.m. Each time you were told a technician would come 'within 24 hours'; no one arrived. The lease says the landlord must maintain heat at 65°F. You want the repair completed by Friday and a written confirmation of the appointment. Your draft opening is: 'I am writing to inform you that my heater is broken and I am very angry.' You are deciding whether to include a sentence saying you will withhold rent, whether to use a formal or conversational tone, and how to organize the request so the manager can act quickly.
1. Evaluate the draft opening. What should be kept, changed, and why?
Read the worked answer
The opening has two problems and one useful element. 'I am writing to inform you' is acceptable in formal email but wordy; ECCE writing rewards directness, so 'I am writing about' or 'I need to report' may be tighter. 'I am very angry' is the larger issue: it states emotion but not facts, and it may make the manager defensive. A firmer opening would state the problem and the record: 'I am writing about the broken heater in apartment 4B, which has left my unit below 60°F for four nights.' Keep the purpose (reporting the problem), replace the emotional label with verifiable detail, and save the impact for the next sentence. That organization gives the manager something to act on.
2. Should you include a threat to withhold rent? Give a recommendation with reasoning.
Read the worked answer
I would not include it in the first email. The task is to get a repair by Friday and written confirmation, and a rent-withholding threat can shift the manager's attention to the dispute rather than the repair. It may also be legally risky if the lease or local law has specific procedures for withholding rent. A better move is to cite the lease's 65°F requirement and the two documented calls, then request a Friday appointment and written confirmation. If the deadline passes, a second email can mention that you will seek advice about your options. That keeps the tone firm and factual while preserving escalation.
3. Propose an organization for the email in three or four moves.
Read the worked answer
Move 1: Identify the problem and the record-unit, heater, four nights below 60°F, and the two calls with dates and times. Move 2: State the impact and the lease obligation-asthma condition, lease requires 65°F. Move 3: Make the request-a repair by Friday and written confirmation of the appointment time. Move 4: Close with contact information and a professional sign-off. This order works because it moves from facts to consequence to action. It also keeps the email within 120–150 words: each move can be one or two sentences. The manager can see what happened, why it matters, and exactly what is needed.