The Timed Email: Choosing the Right Past Reference after 'I'd rather'
You are on Grammar and Vocabulary item 37, with 45 seconds left and two items still to come. The sentence is: 'I'd rather you ______ me about the change before you emailed the client.' Above it, a context sentence reads: 'The email went out on Tuesday; I found out on Wednesday.' You have eliminated (C) tell and (D) would tell, and are left with (A) told and (B) had told. Your memorized pattern is 'I'd rather you went,' so A feels safe. But you notice that the regret is located before the email, and you wonder whether the past subjunctive alone can carry that earlier time. The instruction says to choose the option that best completes the sentence in context.
1. Which option is correct, and how does the timeline decide it?
Read the worked answer
B, 'had told.' 'I'd rather' + past subjunctive ('told') expresses a preference about the present or future: I would prefer that you tell me now or next time. To express a preference about an earlier action - one that cannot now be changed - English uses the past perfect: 'I'd rather you had told me before you emailed.' The context fixes the order: email Tuesday, discovery Wednesday. The speaker is not asking for future behavior; the speaker is expressing regret about a missed earlier warning. A is grammatical but shifts the meaning to a present preference, which contradicts 'found out on Wednesday.' The test is not 'which form follows I'd rather' but 'which time does the preference refer to.'
2. Why is 'would tell' not acceptable here, even though 'would' is a past-form modal?
Read the worked answer
'Would tell' would be interpreted as a conditional or habitual past ('you would tell me' = you used to tell me, or you would have told me under some condition), not as the subjunctive complement selected by 'I'd rather.' The construction selects a bare past or past perfect after the subject: 'I'd rather you told/had told.' Inserting 'would' creates a different structure and a different meaning. This is a case where a form that looks past is doing a modal job, so the safe procedure is to identify the complement type first, then the time reference, and only then choose the tense.
3. Write one parallel sentence with the same structure but a present/future preference, and one with a past regret.
Read the worked answer
Present/future: 'I'd rather you sent the draft before Friday.' Past regret: 'I'd rather you had sent the draft before Friday.' The only difference is the perfect auxiliary, and it maps onto the same timeline distinction: the first is an actionable preference, the second is a closed regret. Keeping the rest of the sentence identical is the point of the exercise: it isolates the time reference as the variable, which is exactly what the item is testing. If you can produce the pair, you are not relying on the memorized 'I'd rather you went' pattern alone.