The Trust Account That 'Netted Out by Friday'
Kim is the qualifying broker of ABC Realty, which employs six salespersons. The office manager deposits every earnest money check received during the week into the firm's general operating account on Friday and moves money to the trust account only 'when a deal gets close,' because the trust account charges a fee whenever the balance falls below $2,500. Last month buyer Nguyen's $12,500 check for a duplex was deposited into the operating account; when that deal collapsed, the manager refunded a different buyer, Osei, $4,000 out of Nguyen's funds and told Kim they would 'net out by Friday.' Separately, Nguyen's earnest money check was returned NSF on a Tuesday. The office did not tell the seller's agent until the following Monday - two days after both parties had signed a mutual cancellation that says nothing about who gets the earnest money.
1. Identify the violations in this fact pattern and rank them by seriousness.
Read the worked answer
Three separate violations, in descending order of severity:
- Using one client's money to pay another client ($4,000 from Nguyen's funds to Osei). This is misappropriation/conversion, not a bookkeeping error. It is grounds for license discipline and possible criminal referral, and it exposes the broker to personal liability for any shortage regardless of intent or later repayment. 'Netting out' is irrelevant - the trust account must be whole at all times.
- Commingling. Earnest money must be deposited in the broker's designated trust account promptly, not parked in the operating account until a closing approaches. Holding client funds in the business account - and letting business cash flow determine when client money is protected - is commingling. The bank's $2,500 minimum-balance fee is a business problem to solve with a different account, never by holding client money outside trust.
- Failure to promptly report the NSF check. Whether the buyer's funds are good is material to the seller's decision to keep the property off the market and to any later claim for breach. Silence for nearly a week, through a cancellation, compounded the problem.
The broker is responsible for funds handled by every licensee and employee in the office, so Kim cannot delegate the blame to the office manager.
2. The seller's agent calls demanding that the earnest money be released to the seller because the buyer's check bounced. What may Kim do?
Read the worked answer
Kim cannot simply pay the seller, and cannot quietly fix the ledger either.
- Kim must first restore the trust account to a correct balance - replacing the $4,000 taken from Nguyen's file and correctly allocating every deposit. Restitution does not erase the violation, but it is the immediate duty.
- The mutual cancellation says nothing about the earnest money. When the parties are silent or in dispute, the broker holds the funds until there is a written agreement signed by both parties directing disbursement, or a court order (or an interpleader if the parties will not agree). The broker does not adjudicate who breached.
- The NSF check matters to the seller's position - the seller may have a claim that the buyer never had funds on deposit - but that is a dispute between the parties, resolved by their written agreement or a court, not by the broker choosing sides.
- What Kim should do: notify both parties in writing that the funds (or the fact that no funds exist) are in dispute, provide the ledger, and ask for a written mutual direction. Document every communication.
3. What recordkeeping and control systems must Kim put in place, and what disclosure obligations does she have about the incident?
Read the worked answer
A compliant operation looks like this:
- A single designated trust account used only for client funds; deposits made promptly (and no later than the deadline in the broker's written policy and the purchase agreement), with the bank given a copy of the broker's authorization to sign.
- A separate ledger for each transaction plus a running checkbook balance, reconciled monthly to the bank statement, with the reconciliation reviewed and signed by the qualifying broker.
- Written policies on handling NSF checks, disputed funds, and disbursement, with procedures that do not route client funds through the operating account for any period.
- Retention of trust records, ledgers, reconciliations, and transaction files for the period required by Minnesota law and rule (generally six years) at a location available for inspection.
- Required notices: the parties must be told promptly if a check is dishonored or funds are missing. Concealment converts a bookkeeping failure into a misrepresentation. Kim should also expect a license investigation and should not destroy or 'reconstruct' records after the fact.