Arsenic and Nitrate Results from a Treated Tap Sample
A new well in north-central Minnesota is sampled 3 days after disinfection. The sample is collected from the kitchen tap after the water softener and carbon filter. Results are total coliform absent, E. coli absent, nitrate 8.2 mg/L as N, arsenic 14 µg/L, manganese 0.9 mg/L, and iron 1.2 mg/L. The lab report notes that lead was not analyzed. The homeowner is pregnant and asks whether the water is safe. The driller says arsenic is naturally occurring and no action is needed because it is below 20 µg/L. The homeowner also has an infant in the home and uses the water for formula. The well has a submersible pump, a pressure tank, and a post-treatment tap at the kitchen sink.
1. Evaluate the sampling procedure. Was this a valid sample for judging raw well water quality? What should have been done differently?
Read the worked answer
The sample is not valid for raw well water quality because it was collected after the softener and carbon filter. Treatment can remove or change arsenic, iron, manganese, and nitrate, and it can also affect bacteria results. Sampling 3 days after disinfection is also risky because chlorine residual can mask coliform bacteria. The driller should collect a raw, untreated sample at the well or a tap before treatment, after flushing and after chlorine is gone. The sample should be in the proper bottle, chilled, and delivered within holding time. Coliform and nitrate are the standard new-well tests; arsenic and manganese should be added where natural groundwater quality is a concern. Lead requires a separate first-draw protocol at the tap.
2. Interpret the reported results against drinking-water standards and health guidance. Which results require action?
Read the worked answer
Arsenic at 14 µg/L exceeds the 10 µg/L federal and state MCL, so action is required. Nitrate at 8.2 mg/L as N is below the 10 mg/L MCL, but it is close to the limit and should be retested; for an infant, low-nitrate water is prudent. Manganese at 0.9 mg/L exceeds the 0.05 mg/L secondary aesthetic standard and may exceed health-based guidance for infants, so treatment or alternative water should be considered. Iron at 1.2 mg/L is mainly aesthetic. Coliform absence is good but not conclusive because the sample was post-treatment and soon after disinfection. Lead was not tested, so it is unknown.
3. What resampling and treatment plan should the driller recommend, including advice for the pregnant homeowner and infant?
Read the worked answer
Resample raw untreated water for coliform, nitrate, arsenic, manganese, and iron, and collect a separate first-draw lead sample at the kitchen tap. Until results are back, use low-arsenic, low-nitrate bottled water for infant formula and for the pregnant homeowner’s drinking water. For arsenic, point-of-use adsorption or reverse osmosis is effective, but the raw arsenic level and treatment performance must be verified. Nitrate can be reduced by reverse osmosis or ion exchange; softening alone is not reliable. Manganese and iron can be treated by oxidation and filtration. Retest treated water after installation and maintain the treatment. The driller should correct the statement that 14 µg/L arsenic is acceptable; it exceeds the MCL.