A Multistate Manufacturer, an Off-List Insurer, and the Home State Rule
Halbrook Precision Metals is incorporated and headquartered in Joplin, Missouri, with plants in Joplin, East St. Louis, Illinois, and Memphis, Tennessee. It has a net worth of $60 million, gross revenues of $180 million, and 800 full-time employees. Its broker, licensed in Missouri as a surplus lines broker, proposes a commercial property and inland marine program at an annual premium of $310,000 with a London insurer that is not on Missouri's eligible list but is on Illinois's qualifying list and holds $40 million in capital and surplus. The CFO emails: "We are a big sophisticated buyer. Skip the declination chase, place it, and just tell me what we owe Missouri."
1. May the broker lawfully place this risk with an insurer that is not on Missouri's eligible surplus lines list?
Read the worked answer
Yes, on these facts, because Halbrook's home state is Missouri and federal nonadmitted insurance law allows a broker to place with an insurer that is not on the home state's list if two conditions are met:
- The insurer appears on the qualifying eligible list of another state (here, Illinois), and
- The insurer maintains capital and surplus at least equal to the federal minimum ($15 million) or the home state minimum, whichever governs.
At $40 million, the insurer clears the threshold comfortably. The state whose list is used must maintain standards meeting the federal benchmark, which Illinois's does.
What does not change is the home state's other rules. Missouri's licensing, disclosure, tax, and recordkeeping requirements apply in full, and the placement is reported to Missouri as the home state. The point of the rule is insurer eligibility, not a waiver of state supervision over the broker.
2. Is the insured an exempt commercial purchaser, and what does that status excuse the broker from doing?
Read the worked answer
Halbrook qualifies as an exempt commercial purchaser. Its net worth ($60 million) exceeds $25 million, its gross revenues ($180 million) exceed $50 million, and it employs more than 500 full-time employees; any one of those tests is sufficient, and it meets three. Size alone is not the test, though: the entity must also use a risk manager or a broker in the purchase, which it does.
Exempt status excuses the diligent search, not the rest of the transaction. The broker still must:
- Advise the insured in writing that the coverage may be available from an authorized insurer, and obtain the insured's written, affirmative request to proceed with a nonadmitted insurer anyway. A CFO's email saying "skip the declination chase" is not the same as a written acknowledgment that admitted coverage may exist.
- Deliver the nonadmitted-insurer disclosure, including that the guaranty association does not apply.
- Confirm insurer eligibility as described above.
- Collect and remit premium tax and keep records supporting each step.
If the broker skips the written acknowledgment, he has converted a lawful shortcut into an undocumented placement.
3. The program covers property in three states. How should the surplus lines premium tax be handled?
Read the worked answer
Missouri is the insured's home state, so under the federal home state rule the entire $310,000 premium is taxed in Missouri and nothing is allocated to Illinois or Tennessee. No Illinois or Tennessee surplus lines tax or stamping fee is due on this multistate risk, and no other state may assert a surplus lines tax on it. This is the single biggest practical difference from pre-2010 practice, when premium was carved up by location and each state taxed its share.
At the 3% Missouri rate, the tax is $9,300, computed on gross premium without deduction for the broker's commission. The broker is personally responsible for remitting it on the annual surplus lines tax return, and the obligation is not contingent on the insured paying. There is one narrow exception worth checking before filing: if Missouri has not been the insured's home state for the entire period, or if the risk is a single-state risk whose home state rule points elsewhere, the analysis changes. Confirm the declarations page lists Joplin as the principal location before relying on the 100% Missouri treatment.