Records Request, Minor Patient, and Contact Lens Prescription
A 16-year-old patient had a comprehensive exam and contact lens fitting. The parent and legal guardian requests a complete copy of the record. The front desk says the $60 balance must be paid first, and the optometrist wants to withhold the record because the patient missed a follow-up appointment and the optometrist is worried about liability. The patient also asks for the contact lens prescription so she can order lenses online. The record contains handwritten notes, a dilated fundus exam, and a referral note. The practice charges $0.50 per page for copies. The parent is the patient's legal guardian and has provided identification.
1. Can the practice withhold the record for the unpaid balance or the missed follow-up?
Read the worked answer
No. Withholding records for an unpaid bill or a missed appointment is generally prohibited. The patient or guardian has a right of access to the record, and the practice may charge only a reasonable, cost-based copying fee. The $0.50 per page may be acceptable if it reflects actual cost and complies with state law, but payment cannot be a precondition to access. The missed follow-up is a clinical issue to document, not a basis to deny the record. Denying access risks Board discipline and privacy-law penalties.
2. Who may request the record for a 16-year-old, and what should the practice verify?
Read the worked answer
The parent or legal guardian generally may request and receive the record for a minor. The practice should verify identity and guardianship, especially if custody is shared or disputed. If state law allows a minor to consent to certain services, the minor may have separate rights for those services; the practice should follow the specific rule rather than assume. Here the guardian has identified herself, so release is appropriate after verification and documentation.
3. Must the contact lens prescription be released to the patient?
Read the worked answer
Yes. The patient is entitled to the contact lens prescription so she can shop elsewhere. The practice cannot require purchase of lenses, a signed waiver, or payment of the balance as a condition of release. A missed follow-up may justify a clinical decision about whether a prescription is current, but the reason must be documented and applied consistently, not used as leverage. The practice should provide the prescription promptly and document the release.