The Parking Lot Handoff
At 6:15 p.m. on a Thursday, a man in his late 40s enters a convenience store and buys two 30-packs of beer and a fifth of vodka. He pays with cash and does not ask for a bag. As he walks out, you see him go to a car in the parking lot where three young people are sitting. The driver's window is down, and a person in the back seat-who looks about 17-hands him a wad of cash through the window. The man laughs and puts the cash in his pocket. Earlier in the week, a different employee reported a similar purchase by the same man. Your store policy says to refuse a sale if you have a reasonable belief the alcohol will be given to a minor. The man has already paid, and the receipt is printing. He is heading for the door.
1. What indicators of a third-party sale are present, and why do they matter?
Read the worked answer
The indicators include the large quantity of alcohol, the cash payment, the waiting car with young occupants, the apparent minor handing cash to the buyer, and the prior similar report. No single indicator proves a third-party sale, but together they create a reasonable belief that the alcohol may be furnished to underage drinkers. The large quantity matters because it exceeds what one person is likely to consume in a short period and is consistent with supplying a group. The cash handoff matters because it suggests the young people are paying the adult to buy for them. The prior report matters because it shows a pattern, not an isolated misunderstanding. Under Montana law and store policy, the seller has a duty not to facilitate furnishing alcohol to minors. The server should act on the reasonable belief, not wait for absolute proof.
2. What should you do right now, given that the man has already paid and is walking out?
Read the worked answer
Act before he leaves if it is safe to do so. Say clearly: 'Sir, I can't complete this sale. I saw cash pass from the car, and I have reason to believe this alcohol is for people under 21.' Offer to void the transaction and refund the payment. Do not physically block the door, grab the alcohol, or chase him into the parking lot; safety comes first. If he refuses the refund and leaves with the alcohol, note the vehicle description and plate if you can do so safely, and notify the manager immediately. If the situation feels threatening or the man appears to be supplying minors, the manager may contact law enforcement. The key is to stop the sale at the register when possible and to avoid a physical confrontation when it is not.
3. How should the incident be documented and used to prevent a repeat?
Read the worked answer
Document the time, the items purchased, the cash payment, the vehicle description, the apparent ages of the occupants, the cash handoff, the refusal or completed sale, and the manager notification. Use factual language and avoid guessing ages beyond 'appeared to be a juvenile.' Include the prior report so the pattern is visible. The manager should review the incident with staff, reinforce the third-party-sale policy, and consider posting a sign at the register. If the same buyer returns, employees should recognize the pattern and refuse the sale before payment. Documentation also supports a police report if law enforcement is involved. The goal is not to accuse every adult who buys a large order, but to respond consistently when specific facts point to underage supply.