Night Hazards on US 2: Deer, a Light Bar, and a Cyclist
You are westbound on US Highway 2 west of Glacier National Park at 9:15 p.m. in mid-September, posted 60 mph, headlights on low beam, clear and dry. Within one mile you meet three hazards. First, a white-tailed deer stands on the right shoulder with its eyes reflecting your lights, and the shoulder drops into a ditch. Second, an oncoming lifted pickup has a roof light bar switched on. Third, a cyclist is ahead in your lane wearing dark clothing with a rear reflector but no taillight, on a stretch with no shoulder and a solid yellow line on your side of the centerline. You have closed to about two seconds behind the cyclist as you slow. Your passenger says to just swerve around the deer and pass the bike before the next curve.
1. What do you do about the deer, and why is swerving the wrong instinct?
Read the worked answer
Eyeshine at close range, on a road with a ditch on the right, is a strong signal that the deer is about to move and that others are likely nearby; September is also a high-movement season. The right response is to lift off the throttle, cover the brake, reduce speed, and prepare to stop in your lane. Do not swerve hard: a swerve into the oncoming lane risks a head-on with the pickup behind the light bar, and a swerve into the ditch risks a rollover. If the deer enters the road, brake firmly in a straight line while steering only enough to stay in your lane, and use the horn. A low-speed strike in a compact car is usually survivable; a rollover into a ditch often is not.
2. The oncoming light bar blinds you. How do you manage those seconds?
Read the worked answer
Look to the right edge of your lane, not at the light bar. Glare destroys your night vision for several seconds after the vehicle passes, and a lifted truck's lights may be aimed above your windshield rather than at the pavement. Slow enough that you can stop within the distance you can actually see, because during those seconds you are functionally driving blind. Do not retaliate with your own high beams: it doubles the glare problem and, if the light bar is a prohibited auxiliary light, that is the other driver's violation to answer for. Someone else's illegal equipment never lowers your own duty to drive at a speed reasonable for the conditions you can perceive.
3. The cyclist has no taillight. Can you pass here, and what does a safe pass require?
Read the worked answer
No. Montana requires a motor vehicle passing a bicycle to leave at least three feet of clearance, and on this stretch you cannot get three feet without crossing the centerline, which the solid yellow on your side forbids. The two-second gap is also too small for a shoulderless road with a slower, unprotected rider. Back off to four or more seconds, wait for a dashed section with a clear sight line and no oncoming traffic, then move left enough to clear three feet and pass briskly. The cyclist's missing taillight is a separate violation; it reduces your ability to see them early but does not reduce your obligation to pass safely - and it is a reason to give more room, not less.