Arranging a Pop Ballad for a Lopsided Middle School Band
You are the new band director at a 7th–8th grade middle school with 34 players: 12 flutes, 6 clarinets, 3 alto saxophones, 2 tenor saxophones, 4 trumpets, 2 trombones, 1 baritone (treble clef), and 4 percussionists. There is no oboe, bassoon, horn, or tuba. You want to arrange a current pop ballad for the spring concert in six weeks. The original is in E major, with a vocal melody that spans a major tenth (B3 to D#5) and a synth bass line that moves in syncopated sixteenths. A first read-through reveals: the melody is barely audible when played by flutes in the written octave; the trombones cannot cleanly articulate the bass line; the baritone player is reading treble clef and is overwhelmed; the clarinets are doubling the alto sax at the unison and sound out of tune; and the percussion parts are ad hoc. The concert is in six weeks, with 40-minute rehearsals twice a week.
1. Choose a concert key and an orchestration plan. Justify both with reference to tessitura, transposition, and balance.
Read the worked answer
Transpose to concert F major. In E major the melody sits at B3–D#5; in F it lies C4–E5, which is comfortable for clarinet clarion and alto sax middle register, and it keeps the flute from living above the staff for the whole song. F also keeps the alto sax out of its palm-key register on the melody and gives the trumpets a manageable written range.
Assign the melody to clarinet and alto sax, but not at the unison. Put clarinet on the melody and alto sax a third below, or alternate phrases. Save the flute octave-above doubling for the final chorus only; otherwise the flutes will either disappear or overpower the reeds. Give the baritone the roots, rewritten in bass clef or as a simplified treble part with letter names, and let the trombones play rhythmic punches on beats 2 and 4 rather than the sixteenth-note bass. Tenor sax can sustain chord tones or take a counterline. Trumpets: two on melody in the last chorus and two on harmony. Percussion should be a kick/snare pattern, hi-hat eighths, and one suspended cymbal. This plan uses the available colors without asking any section to do what it cannot do at this level.
2. Rewrite the syncopated bass line for your available low instruments so it is playable but preserves the groove. Describe and justify the reductions.
Read the worked answer
Preserve harmonic rhythm, downbeats, and the placement of the syncopation; reduce the surface density, not the harmony.
- Baritone: roots on beats 1 and 3, with a fifth or octave on the 'and' of 2 where the chord lasts two beats. If the player is overwhelmed, reduce to roots on beats 1 and 3 with a whole-note sustain. Rewrite in bass clef or provide a treble part with letter names and fingerings.
- Trombones: remove the sixteenth-note bass line entirely. Give them rhythmic punches on beats 2 and 4, or a two-note 'root–fifth' figure that articulates the groove.
- Tenor sax: a sustained chord tone or a simple counterline; do not double the bass at pitch.
The groove survives because the percussion and trombone punches carry the syncopation while the baritone keeps the harmonic foundation legible. Writing sixteenths for trombones at this level produces a smear and teaches them to play with tension. The reduction is a musical decision about function, not just a simplification.
3. Identify one likely cause of the clarinet/alto sax intonation problem and a rehearsal fix that does not rely on telling them to 'listen better.'
Read the worked answer
The likely cause is unison doubling across different bore profiles, vibrato, and register tendencies. Alto sax tends to sit sharp in the upper register and clarinet can sit low in the throat tones; the two instruments also have different tuning tendencies on specific scale degrees. When they play the same pitch at the same time, the beats are exposed and the octave is not there to mask them.
Fix the arrangement first: stop the unison. Give clarinet the melody and alto sax a third below, or alternate phrases. If they must double, tune both to a concert F drone, then have the alto sax play with a slightly cooler airstream and the clarinet with a firm embouchure. Check mouthpiece pitch individually with a tuner. Record eight bars and ask the pair to identify where the beats stop. Then add the rest of the band at mezzo-piano and see whether the interval holds. This addresses voicing and air rather than issuing a vague instruction to listen.