The Student Who Will Not Dress for Required PE
You teach required 10th-grade PE at a large high school. The semester has 45 meetings; D. has attended 31 and has refused to dress or participate in 14 of them. When asked, D. sits on the bleachers with earbuds. Last week D. disclosed to you that changing in the locker room triggers panic about body image and that a pediatrician note says 'may need modified participation.' The student handbook says students who are not dressed lose daily points and may fail; district policy requires 80% participation for credit toward graduation. D. is passing academic quizzes but has a 54% participation grade. There are two weeks left. The counselor is on leave, the assistant principal says 'apply the policy consistently,' and D.'s parent has not returned calls. You have a fitness unit and a team sports unit remaining.
1. What are the legal and ethical considerations in applying the dress and participation policy to D.? Distinguish what you can and cannot do.
Read the worked answer
The pediatrician's note does not by itself create a 504 plan, but it does trigger the school's child-find obligation: a health or mental-health condition that substantially limits a major life activity, including learning or concentrating, may require evaluation. You cannot unilaterally decide that D. is 'just refusing' and fail the student if the nonparticipation is disability-related. You also cannot lower the essential participation standard to zero or give credit for attendance only. Ethically, you must protect D.'s privacy, avoid public shaming at the bleachers, and avoid discussing the body-image disclosure with other students. What you can do is enforce safe attire, require on-task behavior, offer private changing and alternative roles, and document everything. What you cannot do is diagnose anxiety, promise confidentiality you cannot keep, or apply the policy inconsistently while telling the assistant principal you are doing so. The correct move is to refer to the student support team and ask for a formal determination while providing interim accommodations.
2. Design a two-week plan that gives D. a realistic path to credit without lowering the standards. Include specific accommodations and how you will measure participation.
Read the worked answer
Meet privately and write a short agreement. Accommodations: arrive 5 minutes early to change in a private office or nurse's bathroom; wear school-appropriate athletic clothing from home if the uniform is the barrier; choose a preferred entry activity; start with a 10-minute goal and build to 20 minutes of moderate-to-vigorous activity. Offer meaningful roles that still require movement and knowledge: peer coach for a station, fitness-journal recorder who demonstrates exercises, or referee who must move with the game. Measure participation by time on task, a simple heart-rate or RPE check, and a daily exit slip with three questions about the lesson. Do not measure 'dressed' as the only proxy. Two weeks is short; the realistic target is 8 of 10 days of 20 minutes, plus completion of the fitness log. If D. refuses, the plan should state the consequence neutrally and trigger a team review rather than an argument. This preserves the 80% participation standard while removing the locker-room barrier.
3. How should you grade and document this, and what if D. still does not participate?
Read the worked answer
Grade academic knowledge and participation separately. The quizzes show content knowledge; the participation grade should reflect observable engagement, not clothing. Document the accommodations offered, D.'s response, the dates, and the individuals consulted. Keep the record factual and private. If D. still does not participate, do not invent points or pass the student on effort alone; refer to the student support team for a 504 evaluation and ask the administrator to clarify the policy in writing. If the team determines no disability-related need, apply the handbook consistently. If it determines a need, the team writes accommodations, and you implement them. The judgment call is to avoid both extremes: granting unearned credit and rigidly failing a student whose barrier you have not evaluated.