Related-Party Mixer Price and Undisclosed Assists
An importer buys 1,500 countertop mixers from its foreign parent at $120 per unit, total $180,000 FOB. At the same time, the parent sells the same model to unrelated buyers in the same country at $150 per unit, total $225,000, at the same commercial level. The importer provides the parent, free of charge, a production mold worth $30,000 that is used exclusively for this order and has not been used before. The importer also pays $9,000 to an unrelated engineering firm for design work performed outside the country of import and necessary for producing the mixers. It pays a 3% selling commission to a foreign sales agent and a $5,000 trademark royalty to the parent that is a condition of sale. International freight and insurance to the port are $7,500; post-importation installation is $4,000. The broker must decide whether the $180,000 price can be accepted and, if so, what value to declare.
1. Can the related-party transaction value be accepted? Apply the circumstances-of-sale test and identify facts that cut both ways.
Read the worked answer
The related-party price is not automatically rejected, but it is at risk. Transaction value is acceptable only if the relationship did not influence the price. The parent's sales of the same model to unrelated buyers at $150 per unit, versus $120 to the importer, at the same commercial level and time, is a 20% gap and a strong signal that Customs will examine the circumstances of sale. The importer can try to show that the lower price reflects legitimate factors-e.g., lower selling costs, quantity, or market conditions-but the file as stated does not explain the gap. If the importer cannot rebut the concern, the price is not acceptable and the broker must move to the sequential fallback methods. The broker should not simply accept the invoice because the parties are related.
2. Assume the transaction value is accepted. Calculate the customs value and identify each addition or exclusion.
Read the worked answer
Use the accepted transaction value and add the statutory elements. Start with $180,000. Add the $30,000 mold: it is a free-of-charge assist used in production; because it is exclusive to this order and not previously used, include its full value (apportion if later used for multiple shipments). Add $9,000 for engineering/design performed outside the country of import and necessary for production. Add the 3% selling commission: 0.03 × $180,000 = $5,400; selling commissions are added, while buying commissions are not. Add the $5,000 trademark royalty because it is a condition of sale. Add $7,500 freight and insurance to the port. Exclude the $4,000 post-importation installation. Customs value = $180,000 + $30,000 + $9,000 + $5,400 + $5,000 + $7,500 = $236,900. If any commission was already included in the invoice price, do not add it twice.
3. If the related-party price is rejected, what valuation method should be used next and what adjustments would you make?
Read the worked answer
If the related-party value is rejected, proceed sequentially. The next method is transaction value of identical goods. The parent's sale of the same model to unrelated buyers at $225,000 is the best starting point, but adjust for differences in commercial level, quantity, and delivery terms so it is comparable to the imported shipment. If those sales are not comparable, try similar goods, then deductive value, then computed value. Do not jump to computed value while identical-goods data exist. If the corrected value produces an underpayment, correct the entry and consider prior disclosure before Customs begins an investigation.