Neo's Car Loan Decision
Neo is 24 and works as a receptionist in Gaborone, earning P5,200 a month after tax. She lives with her mother and pays P1,200 rent, P450 transport, P900 food, P300 electricity and water, and P250 airtime and data. She also has a store account with an outstanding balance of P3,600, which charges 22% interest a year and requires a minimum payment of P300 a month. Neo wants to buy a second-hand car costing P28,000. A bank has offered a five-year car loan at 15% interest, which would add about P680 to her monthly payments, plus P600 for insurance, fuel and maintenance. She has P1,500 in savings. Her friend says she should take the loan now because 'everyone needs a car'. Neo asks for advice on whether to buy the car, how to handle the store account, and how to build savings.
1. Using the figures given, prepare Neo's monthly budget before she takes the car loan. Calculate her disposable income and comment on whether the car is affordable.
Read the worked answer
Budget before the car loan
| Item | Amount (P) |
|---|---|
| Rent | 1,200 |
| Transport | 450 |
| Food | 900 |
| Electricity and water | 300 |
| Airtime and data | 250 |
| Store account minimum | 300 |
| Total outflows | 3,400 |
Disposable income = P5,200 - P3,400 = P1,800.
If Neo takes the car
Add loan repayment P680 + running costs P600 = P1,280. Remaining = P1,800 - P1,280 = P520 a month.
The car would absorb about 71% of her disposable income (1,280 / 1,800). That leaves P520 for clothing, medical costs, emergencies and any store-account payment above the minimum. On affordability alone, the car is risky: one unexpected expense could force her to borrow more. A lender may approve the loan, but approval is not the same as affordability. The better judgement is that she cannot comfortably afford the car yet.
2. Advise Neo on whether to take the car loan now. Consider the store account, depreciation and risk.
Read the worked answer
Neo should delay the car loan. The reasoning is:
- High-interest debt first. The store account charges 22%, which is more than the car loan's 15%. Every extra pula used to reduce the store balance gives a better financial return than borrowing for a car that loses value.
- Depreciation and total cost. A second-hand car falls in value, and P600 a month may be too low once repairs, tyres, licence and unexpected breakdowns are included.
- Emergency fund. She has only P1,500 in savings. The car would leave a P520 buffer, which is too thin.
- Credit record. Missing a repayment would damage her credit record and make future borrowing harder.
A practical plan is to use the P1,800 disposable income to pay P800-P1,000 a month to the store account, build savings to at least three months' essential expenses, and save a deposit. She should revisit the car in 6-9 months when the store balance is cleared and her savings are stronger. If a car is essential for work, a cheaper model or shared transport is a better first step.
3. Explain two responsible money-management actions Neo can take over the next 12 months to improve her financial position.
Read the worked answer
Action 1: Prioritise the store account. Pay P800 a month instead of the P300 minimum. The extra P500 reduces the balance and the interest charged. At 22% a year, a P3,600 balance costs roughly P66 a month in interest at the start; reducing the balance saves part of that cost. Once the account is cleared, redirect the P800 to savings. This is responsible because it removes expensive debt before adding new debt.
Action 2: Build an emergency fund in a separate savings account. Aim for P3,000-P5,000, roughly one to two months' essential expenses. This prevents new borrowing when a phone breaks or a medical cost arises. It also reduces the need to use the store account for emergencies.
She should also track her spending for one month to find small leaks, avoid 'buy now, pay later' offers, and compare insurance quotes before buying a car. A budget is not a punishment; it is a plan that protects her choices.