Science Club Report: Ordering, Tone, and Length
A middle school science club has drafted six sentences for the 'program results' section of its annual report, but they were pasted in scrambled order, and one sentence does not belong: (A) 'Last September the club placed labelled recycling bins in every corridor.' (B) 'Within a week, students were sorting paper, cans, and bottles without being reminded.' (C) 'The first month, however, brought a setback: juice cartons kept landing in the paper bins.' (D) 'Volunteers solved this by adding a fourth bin and a poster at each stairwell.' (E) 'By December the school had diverted 1.2 tonnes of paper from landfill.' (F) 'Our football team also won the regional final in October.' The faculty adviser wants a paragraph of five sentences in logical order, a clear opening sentence, and no sentence longer than 25 words. The club president thinks the order 'doesn't matter much' because each sentence is true.
1. Give the correct order of the five relevant sentences and justify it with reference to specific words, not just to chronology.
Read the worked answer
Order: A, B, C, D, E. A opens by fixing time and action ('Last September... placed labelled bins'). B reports the immediate result and depends on A through 'Within a week.' C cannot precede B, because 'however' needs a prior positive statement to contrast with, and it names the first month. D must follow C because 'solved this' has no referent unless C's juice-carton problem comes first. E closes because 'By December' requires time to elapse after September and it reports the cumulative outcome. F is excluded: nothing in it links lexically to bins, sorting, or tonnage. The president's view fails because 'this' and 'however' are anaphoric - they carry meaning from earlier sentences, so order is part of the content.
2. The club president drafted a replacement for sentence C: 'The first month was a total disaster because kids kept throwing juice cartons in the paper bins.' Revise it for the report and explain each change.
Read the worked answer
Revision: 'The first month brought one setback: juice cartons repeatedly ended up in the paper bins.' 'Total disaster' overstates a single sorting problem and contradicts the club's own results later in the paragraph; scale the wording to the evidence. 'Kids' is informal for a report read by adults, so use 'students,' or leave the actors unnamed as above. 'Kept throwing' implies deliberate mischief, while 'repeatedly ended up' reports the observable outcome and avoids accusing anyone. Keep the admission itself - a report that records a problem and a fix is more credible than one that reports only success, and sentence D needs that problem to make sense.
3. Combine sentences A and B into one sentence of no more than 30 words, keeping the information the paragraph needs later, and explain what you cut and why.
Read the worked answer
Combined: 'Last September the club placed labelled recycling bins in every corridor, and within a week students were sorting paper, cans, and bottles unprompted.' That is 24 words. Kept: the date, the agent, the action, the location, and the result, because sentence C's 'however' and sentence E's 'By December' depend on that timeline. Cut: 'without being reminded,' replaced by 'unprompted,' which carries the same meaning in one word. Do not cut 'labelled' or 'every corridor' - they explain why the sorting worked. Avoid compressing to 'Bins were placed and students sorted,' which hides the club behind passive voice and loses the time frame the rest of the paragraph relies on. Test any combination by asking what later sentences point back to.