Partial Disability, Group Offsets, and Taxability for a Surgeon
Dr. Alvarez, 38, is an orthopedic surgeon with base salary of $420,000. Her group long-term disability plan covers 60% of the first $250,000 of salary, pays a maximum of $12,500 per month, and offsets Social Security disability and individual disability benefits dollar for dollar. Premiums are employer-paid, so benefits are taxable. She also owns an individual own-occupation policy bought during residency: $5,000 per month, 90-day elimination period, no cost-of-living rider, no residual disability benefit, premiums paid with after-tax dollars. She has developed rheumatoid arthritis with intermittent hand pain. She continues to operate but has cut back to 70% of her prior schedule, and her income is down about 30%. She asks whether she can claim benefits and whether she should buy more coverage.
1. Analyze whether Dr. Alvarez can claim under the group and individual policies given her reduced schedule.
Read the worked answer
The group policy is the more likely source of partial benefits, but only if it contains a residual or partial disability provision. Many group LTD plans pay a proportional benefit when income loss exceeds a threshold, often 20%, and she is at 30%. If the group plan defines disability as inability to perform her own occupation for an initial period, her reduced schedule and hand pain may satisfy the definition, but she must document the functional limitations and the income loss. If the plan has no residual provision, a claim while still operating is much weaker.
The individual policy is a bigger problem. It is own-occupation, but it has no residual benefit. Total disability usually requires that she be unable to perform the material and substantial duties of her occupation. Working 70% of a surgical schedule suggests she can still perform those duties, even with pain. She should not assume the individual policy will pay; the insurer may treat the claim as not total disability. She should request the policy's exact definition and any presumptive disability or loss-of-earnings language before filing.
2. Calculate the likely benefit mix and explain the tax and offset consequences.
Read the worked answer
Assume Social Security disability benefits of $2,800 per month. The group plan's gross benefit is $12,500. It offsets both the $5,000 individual benefit and the $2,800 Social Security benefit: $12,500 − $5,000 − $2,800 = $4,700 from the group plan. Total monthly income is $4,700 + $5,000 + $2,800 = $12,500, or 36% of her $420,000 salary.
The tax treatment matters. The group benefit is taxable because premiums were employer-paid, so the $4,700 is reduced by ordinary income tax. The individual benefit is tax-free because she paid premiums with after-tax dollars. The Social Security benefit may be partly taxable depending on total income. Without the individual policy, the group benefit would be $9,700 but fully taxable, so the individual policy adds after-tax value even though it reduces the group payment dollar for dollar.
She should confirm whether the group plan offsets the individual benefit and whether the offset applies before or after taxation. Some plans offset gross benefits, which is harsher.
3. Recommend how she should address her coverage gap and policy design going forward.
Read the worked answer
She should apply for additional individual disability coverage now, while she is still working and before the arthritis progresses. Insurability is already impaired, so the carrier may rate the policy, exclude the hands, or decline; waiting increases that risk. She should ask for own-occupation, residual disability, a cost-of-living adjustment, a future increase option, and noncancelable and guaranteed renewable provisions. A future increase option is valuable because her income may rise and her health may change.
She should also examine business overhead expense coverage if she owns her practice, and a disability buy-out policy if partners need funding to purchase her interest. She should not rely on the group plan alone: it is taxable, offset-heavy, capped at $12,500, and terminable by the employer.
Before filing any claim, she should obtain the plan documents and calculate the exact offset formula. If the individual policy has no residual benefit, she should not file a total-disability claim based on a 30% income loss without legal review; a denied claim can complicate future underwriting.