Dual-Income Couple With Competing Goals and Thin Reserves
Maria and Dev, both 39, have combined gross income of $186,000 and take-home pay of $9,400 per month. Their balance sheet shows $14,000 in checking/savings, $62,000 in 401(k)s, $28,000 in a brokerage account, a $310,000 mortgage at 6.25% with 27 years remaining, $36,000 in federal student loans at 5.4%, and $19,000 on a credit card at 22.9%. They have two children, ages 6 and 3. Monthly obligations include $2,310 mortgage, $650 student loan, $420 credit card minimum, $1,850 childcare, $1,100 food, $600 transportation, and $350 insurance. They want to fund college at $120,000 per child in today's dollars, retire at 67, and replace a 12-year-old car within 18 months. Their emergency fund target is six months of essential expenses. Dev's employer offers a 5% 401(k) match; Maria's employer does not. They have no disability insurance beyond a small group policy and no wills.
1. Calculate the emergency fund target and identify the most urgent trade-offs. What should Maria and Dev do in the next 12 months?
Read the worked answer
Essential monthly expenses: mortgage $2,310 + student loan $650 + credit-card minimum $420 + childcare $1,850 + food $1,100 + transportation $600 + insurance $350 = $7,280. Six months is $43,680; three months is $21,840. Their $14,000 cash reserve is below even three months, and the $28,000 brokerage account is not a true emergency reserve because it can lose value and may create tax costs when sold.
Next 12 months - order of operations:
- Keep Dev's 5% 401(k) contribution to capture the full match; it is an immediate return that is hard to replicate.
- Build cash to at least $22,000, then to $44,000, using the monthly surplus (about $2,120 before irregular costs) and any bonus.
- Attack the 22.9% credit card after a starter cash cushion; do not use the entire brokerage account for this if it would leave them illiquid.
- Keep student loan and mortgage payments current; neither is as urgent as the card, but the 6.25% mortgage is worth reviewing after the card is gone.
- Put a modest amount into a car sinking fund rather than financing a replacement with a long loan.
The $120,000-per-child college goal is $240,000 in today's dollars and should not outrank the match, emergency fund, high-interest debt, or income protection. A funded 529 can follow once the foundation is stable.
2. They ask whether to pause retirement contributions to pay off the credit card and student loans. Evaluate their options.
Read the worked answer
Do not stop the Dev 401(k) contribution below the match. A 5% employer match is an immediate, risk-free return on the contributed salary; pausing it to pay debt gives up that return and tax deferral. The question is what to do with money above the match.
Credit card first. A 22.9% after-tax cost is higher than any reasonable expected return on a balanced portfolio. After a small cash cushion, direct surplus to the card. A balance transfer can help only if the fee is low, the promotional rate is long enough, and they will not run the card back up.
Student loan next. At 5.4%, the loan is cheaper than the card but still a guaranteed cost. If the interest is tax-deductible, the effective cost is lower, so it may be reasonable to pay it on schedule while keeping above-match 401(k) contributions. The 6.25% mortgage is also a guaranteed cost but is long-term and less urgent than the card.
Judgment: keep the match, pause only above-match retirement contributions temporarily, and restore them once the card and a six-month reserve are handled. Do not drain the brokerage and cash accounts so deeply that a job loss forces new high-interest debt.
3. What insurance and estate-planning gaps should be addressed now, and why are they urgent given the children's ages?
Read the worked answer
Insurance gaps: The small group disability policy is likely insufficient. Group coverage often replaces only a limited percentage of base pay, may be taxable if employer-paid, and may not be own-occupation. With two young children and a $186,000 household income, an individual disability policy should be evaluated to protect earning power. Life insurance should also be reviewed: term coverage on both parents should cover debts, childcare, college contributions, and income replacement, not just one year of salary.
Estate-planning gaps: They need wills naming a guardian for the children, a trust or custodial arrangement to manage assets for minors, durable powers of attorney, and health-care directives. Beneficiary designations on 401(k)s and life insurance should be checked so they do not override the will.
Why now: Without a will, a court may decide guardianship. Without a trust, a minor could receive assets outright at 18 or 21. These are low-cost, high-consequence fixes and should be completed before the next school year.