English Test: Revising a Public Water Notice
Residents of Kalahari East are advised that the water point on Kudu Street will be closed on Friday 14 March for repairs. It will reopen on Saturday 15 March at 06:00. Residents who collect water from this point should store enough for the day. The committee thanks residents for their patience and apologises for any inconvenience. Those who have not paid their monthly levy should do so at the office before the closure. The water point serves about 240 households, and no alternative standpipe is within walking distance. The committee has arranged for a tanker to supply water at the community hall from 10:00 to 14:00 on Friday only. Residents should bring their own containers. The committee will announce any further changes on the notice board.
1. The sentence 'Residents who collect water from this point should store enough for the day' is unclear. Identify the ambiguity and rewrite the sentence so that a reader knows exactly what to do.
Read the worked answer
'For the day' can mean Friday, the whole weekend, or an unspecified period. The notice also does not say how much water a household should store. A precise version is: 'Residents who usually collect water from the Kudu Street point should store enough water for Friday 14 March, because the tanker at the community hall will operate only from 10:00 to 14:00.' This fixes the date and connects the instruction to the tanker. The revision still does not give a quantity, but quantity depends on household size; the committee could add 'about 20 litres per person' if it has that guidance.
2. The final sentence about unpaid levies comes after the apology. What effect is it likely to have, and how should the committee revise it if the intended message is 'pay your levy, but the closure is not a punishment'?
Read the worked answer
Placing the levy warning immediately after 'apologises for any inconvenience' creates a link between the closure and unpaid levies. A reader may infer that the water point is being closed because some residents have not paid, even though the first sentence says the closure is for repairs. That damages trust and may make the notice feel threatening. To separate the messages, move the levy sentence to its own short paragraph, add a clear reason and use a neutral verb: 'Separately, the committee asks households with unpaid monthly levies to settle them at the office before 30 April. This does not affect the repair schedule.' The word 'separately' and the explicit denial break the false cause-and-effect link.
3. The notice says a tanker will supply water 'on Friday only'. A resident who works from 08:00 to 17:00 says the notice is useless. Is this a failure of the notice or of the resident's reading? Explain what the committee should add.
Read the worked answer
It is mainly a failure of the notice's planning, not the resident's reading. The notice does state the tanker hours (10:00 to 14:00), so a careful reader can see the service is unavailable after 17:00. But the notice does not say what people who cannot attend should do. A useful notice anticipates constraints. The committee should add one of three options: an evening tanker slot, a neighbour-collection arrangement, or a contact number for vulnerable households. It should also state whether the 240 households are expected to share the tanker and whether containers are limited. This turns a factual announcement into an actionable instruction.