Foster Care, Kinship Caregiver, and Family Involvement
Aaliyah is a 15-year-old girl who has been in foster care for two years and is placed with her maternal aunt, Ms. Carter, along with her 9-year-old brother. Aaliyah uses cannabis nearly daily and alcohol on weekends, has missed 22 school days this semester, and was caught shoplifting. Ms. Carter says she is "at the end of my rope" and wants Aaliyah placed in residential treatment. Aaliyah's biological mother has opioid use disorder, is in recovery, and has supervised visitation; she wants to be involved in treatment. The child welfare agency has legal custody and refers Aaliyah for assessment. Aaliyah says her aunt "only cares about my brother" and that her mother "chooses drugs over me."
1. Who can consent to treatment and who should be included in the family systems intervention? Justify your answer.
Read the worked answer
Consent must come from the legal custodian. The child welfare agency has legal custody; therefore, the agency consents to assessment and treatment, and the caseworker should sign. Ms. Carter, as kinship caregiver, can give routine consent for emergency care and should be included as the primary caregiver, but she may not have legal authority for SUD treatment.
The biological mother's rights depend on whether her parental rights were terminated or limited; if she retains medical or educational consent rights, the agency and mother must coordinate. Ethically, include mother with agency approval and Aaliyah's assent, especially because abandonment and loyalty conflicts are central. A family systems plan should include Ms. Carter, Aaliyah, her brother when appropriate, and mother in separate or conjoint sessions if safe. Do not treat Aaliyah in isolation. Clarify roles in writing and avoid asking Aaliyah to choose between caregivers.
2. How would you weigh residential treatment against intensive outpatient with family involvement? What family dynamics and systemic factors matter?
Read the worked answer
Residential is not automatically indicated. ASAM dimensions show cannabis and alcohol use, truancy, and shoplifting, but no withdrawal risk, medical instability, or acute danger. The more pressing issue is family and system instability: Ms. Carter feels overwhelmed, Aaliyah feels displaced by her brother, and mother's recovery is a source of loss.
Least restrictive care-intensive outpatient with family therapy, multi-family groups, in-home case management, and school re-engagement-may be more effective and less disruptive than removing her from the only stable home. Residential could increase trauma and disrupt sibling bonds. However, if she escalates to daily intoxication, fails outpatient, or becomes unsafe, reassess for higher care. Address Ms. Carter's burnout with respite and parenting support, and involve mother in a structured family session only if safe. Use the caseworker to reinforce placement stability.