The Missing Case File A-2047
You are the records clerk in a county assistance office. A case file for client A-2047 is requested by the fraud unit and by the client's new caseworker on the same morning. The checkout log shows the file was loaned to Program Services on March 3 and returned March 10. It is not in the A-2000 drawer. A sticky note inside the drawer says 'scanning - batch 44' dated March 11. The scanning log shows batch 44 was received March 12, completed March 14, and returned to 'records' on March 14, but no shelf location is recorded. While searching, you find a file labeled A-2074 in the A-2047 folder slot; inside are documents bearing A-2047's name and a confidentiality notice. The fraud unit needs the original by 2:00 p.m.; the caseworker can accept a scanned copy. Your supervisor is at lunch until 1:00 p.m. and cannot be reached by phone.
1. What is the most likely explanation for the missing file, and what confidentiality risk do you see?
Read the worked answer
Most likely explanation: The file was probably misfiled after scanning. The scanning log shows it returned to records on March 14 but gives no shelf location. The A-2047 folder slot contains an A-2074 folder holding A-2047 documents. That suggests someone returned the file to the wrong slot or swapped folders during re-filing. A second possibility is that the original is still in the scanning area or on a return cart, and only a copy was filed.
Confidentiality risk: Documents bearing A-2047's name are sitting inside a folder labeled A-2074. Anyone pulling A-2074 could see another client's confidential information. This is a potential unauthorized disclosure. The documents should be secured immediately, not left in the wrong folder. Also, do not release the A-2074 folder to anyone until the contents are sorted and the correct file is located.
2. List the steps you would take, in order, to locate and secure the file before 2:00 p.m.
Read the worked answer
- Secure the misfiled documents: Remove the A-2047 documents from the A-2074 folder, place them in a locked drawer or a confidential envelope, and note where they were found and the time.
- Search the A-2074 slot and nearby drawers: The missing A-2047 file may have been placed where A-2074 belongs.
- Check the scanning area and return cart for batch 44 and any unshelved files.
- Ask scanning staff whether batch 44 originals were returned to records or held for quality review.
- Check the digital scan to confirm the file was imaged and to obtain a copy if the original is delayed.
- Document the search with times, locations checked, and names of people contacted.
- Escalate at 1:00 p.m. to the supervisor if the original is still missing; do not wait until 2:00 p.m.
Do not release the A-2074 file or leave the misfiled documents unsecured while searching.
3. How would you respond to the fraud unit and the caseworker, and what would you tell your supervisor at 1:00 p.m.?
Read the worked answer
To the fraud unit: Acknowledge the 2:00 p.m. deadline. Tell them the original is being located and that you will provide a status update by 12:30 p.m. If the original is not found, offer a certified scanned copy and explain that the original is being searched for, rather than promising something you cannot deliver. Do not disclose the A-2074 mix-up to unauthorized parties.
To the caseworker: Provide a scanned copy once you confirm it is the correct client's file. The caseworker can accept a scan, so this does not require the original. Note the release in the file log.
To your supervisor at 1:00 p.m.: Report the facts: the file is missing from the A-2000 drawer; A-2047 documents were found inside the A-2074 folder; the scanning log shows return without a shelf location; the fraud unit needs the original by 2:00 p.m.; and the caseworker has been offered a scan. State what you have secured and what remains unresolved. Ask for direction on notifying privacy or compliance staff if the misfiling is treated as a potential breach.