Distal Radius ORIF: A Patient Pushing Past the Protocol
Ms. T is a 55-year-old self-employed hairstylist, 6 weeks after volar plate ORIF of a distal radius fracture. She presents with wrist AROM of 25 degrees flexion and 20 degrees extension, 30 degrees supination, visible dorsal edema, and pain 7/10 at end range. Her surgeon's protocol allows active and gentle passive range of motion but no resisted exercise or loading until week 8. She has not done her home program 'because it hurts,' has no income while off work, and tells you, 'Just push it hard - I have to be back in the chair cutting hair in three weeks.' She also mentions new tingling in her thumb, index, and middle fingers that wakes her at night.
1. What do you address first this session, and how do you sequence the rest of the treatment?
Read the worked answer
Reasoning: The new median-distribution paresthesias are the highest-priority finding because they are new, not explained by the fracture alone, and could indicate nerve irritation that aggressive treatment would worsen. They outrank range of motion.
Sequence:
- Screen the symptom pattern (location, timing, positions that provoke it, night symptoms, relationship to swelling and splint use). Handle provocation tests cautiously - they can aggravate symptoms and are not diagnostic on their own.
- Manage edema (elevation, retrograde massage, compression as appropriate), since swelling both limits motion and increases carpal tunnel pressure.
- Notify the surgeon the same day and request guidance on positioning, night splinting, and whether to modify range of motion.
- Then treat within protocol: active range of motion, tendon gliding, scar management, light functional use - no resistance or loading before week 8.
- Revisit the home program as a problem to solve (pain, timing, confidence), not a compliance failure: shorten it, tie it to daily routines, and check technique.
Document the new symptoms, who you notified, and what changed in the plan.
2. She wants you to push past the protocol so she can return to full hairstyling in three weeks. How do you respond?
Read the worked answer
Reasoning: Her deadline is financial and real; the tissue timeline is not negotiable. These are not in conflict if the goal is redefined from 'full duty in three weeks' to 'the fastest safe path to earning again.'
- Be direct about healing: the plate is stable, but tendon and soft tissue tolerance at 6 weeks does not allow loading, and forcing range of motion now can produce a worse setback than three weeks of patience.
- Show the gap between her job demands and her current capacity: sustained wrist extension, firm grip, repetitive cutting, overhead reach, and hours on her feet.
- Build a work-simulation ladder you can start now: simulated cutting with graded resistance timing, tool handle adaptations, supported elbow positioning, endurance intervals, and task pacing.
- Plan for a modified or part-time return first (longer appointment slots, limited hours, lighter clients) and offer to speak with her about how to frame that to clients and her landlord/income situation.
- Tell her explicitly that being self-employed changes her finances, not her tissue healing, and that you will not promise a full-duty date - you will give her measurable criteria to aim at.
- Record her goal in her own words in the plan of care so the team sees the driver.
3. How do you structure the home program and outcome measurement for the next four weeks?
Read the worked answer
Reasoning: A home program that reproduces pain will be abandoned again, and abandoned programs remove the main lever for change between visits. Measurement should track both impairment and the occupation she cares about.
Home program design:
- Two to three items only, each tied to something she already does (after coffee, after lunch, before bed).
- Pain-guided dosing: perform to a tolerable stretch, not to a 7/10; stop and elevate if symptoms escalate.
- Include edema control and positioning during her day, not just exercises.
- Provide written and visual instructions and confirm she can reproduce them before she leaves.
Measurement:
- Impairment: AROM for flexion, extension, supination, and pronation at each visit with the same positioning; grip strength only when the protocol allows.
- Edema: circumferential measurement at a fixed landmark.
- Function: a validated upper-extremity patient-report measure plus a timed simulated work task (for example, minutes of simulated cutting before symptom onset) as a work-capacity indicator.
- Symptoms: median nerve symptom frequency and night wakings.
Review the numbers with her each visit so progress is visible even when the calendar feels slow.