The 504 Plan Nobody Implemented
Devon is a 12-year-old seventh grader with a 504 plan for generalized anxiety disorder. The plan, written 14 months ago, includes "present oral presentations to the teacher privately before or after class" and "may leave class for a five-minute reset without a pass." Devon's new social studies teacher, Mr. Patel, tells you he never received the plan and that the accommodation is "unfair to the other kids." He has required Devon to present in front of the class twice; both times Devon froze and received a zero. Devon now refuses to attend social studies, and grades have dropped from B to D. Devon's mother emails you: "You are the counselor. Fix this by Friday or I am calling a lawyer." The 504 coordinator is on medical leave, and the assistant principal says the teacher is "old school" and to "give it time."
1. What is your role and what is not your role in this situation? Explain how you would clarify both to the mother, the teacher, and the assistant principal.
Read the worked answer
My role is to support Devon's access, advocate for implementation, and help the adults communicate. I am not the 504 coordinator, I cannot unilaterally amend the plan, and I cannot promise the mother a legal outcome. Saying that clearly is not passing the buck; it prevents the mother from relying on a promise I cannot keep and prevents the teacher from hearing me as an enforcer with no authority.
To the mother, I would say: "I am not the district's 504 coordinator, and I cannot change the plan alone. What I can do is make sure the plan reaches the people who must implement it, get Devon support this week, and connect you with the person who can formally address compliance. I will confirm in writing what I have done by Friday." That is responsive without overclaiming.
To Mr. Patel, I would avoid a compliance lecture. I would say: "This is an existing accommodation, not a new request. Here is the copy you should have received. Let's talk about how to make the private presentation work without adding to your load." I would offer to help arrange the space or timing.
To the assistant principal, I would be direct: "Waiting risks escalation and further loss of instructional time. I need you to authorize the interim accommodation while the coordinator is out." The counselor's leverage here is documentation and escalation, not authority.
2. Outline the steps you would take before Friday, including who you would involve and in what order, and the reasoning behind that sequence.
Read the worked answer
I would sequence by risk of harm first, then compliance, then relationship repair.
Monday: email Mr. Patel a copy of the plan and request a 15-minute meeting. Also email the assistant principal summarizing the concern in neutral, factual language and asking for interim authorization. Contact the district 504 office to ask who is covering the coordinator's duties. The reason to do this in writing is that a paper trail protects Devon and gives the mother a factual response by Friday.
Tuesday: meet with Mr. Patel. Bring the plan, a one-page explanation of why the accommodation exists, and two concrete options: present to him before school, or record the presentation and have him ask questions afterward. Ask him what support he needs. The goal is implementation, not a confession.
Wednesday: meet with Devon. Ask what would make social studies tolerable this week, including a temporary alternate setting for the next presentation. Do not require Devon to advocate alone to Mr. Patel.
Thursday: confirm with the district office whether a formal compliance review will occur and who will contact the mother. Send the mother a written summary of actions taken and the name and contact information of the responsible administrator. Copy the assistant principal.
Friday: check whether the accommodation was actually offered and whether Devon attended class. If not, escalate in writing to the principal, because a plan that exists on paper but is not implemented is the core problem.
Why this order: the student's immediate access comes first, the teacher needs information before he can comply, and the mother needs a truthful, documented response rather than reassurance.
3. How would you support Devon emotionally while the compliance issue is resolved, and what would you document?
Read the worked answer
I would separate Devon's emotional experience from the adults' dispute. Devon has had two public failures and now avoids class, so the first goal is to reduce shame and restore a sense of control. I would meet once to normalize anxiety, name what happened without blaming Devon, and identify one or two coping strategies for the next presentation. I would ask whether Devon wants to rehearse with me or with a trusted teacher. I would also ask about sleep, appetite, and avoidance in other classes, because anxiety that is spreading beyond social studies changes the intervention.
I would not turn counseling into case management. If Devon needs ongoing therapy, I would discuss a referral with the mother rather than trying to treat the anxiety in brief school sessions.
Documentation would include: dates of contact with the mother, Mr. Patel, the assistant principal, and the district office; the exact accommodation language; whether it was offered and when; Devon's reports of what happened in class; any referral made; and the written summary sent to the mother. I would keep the notes factual and avoid characterizations such as "teacher is resistant" or "mother is litigious." If the mother raises legal action, I would not discuss legal strategy; I would route that to administration and continue documenting implementation.