Monday Morning After
On a Sunday night, a 16-year-old junior at your high school dies by suicide. By Monday 7:00 a.m., students are posting on Instagram that he "couldn't take it anymore" and naming the method; a senior has created a GoFundMe for a memorial bench and is selling T-shirts with a slogan. The principal calls you at 6:45 a.m. and says, "We're doing an assembly first period. I want you to talk about suicide prevention and show that video the district made. And the football team wants to wear his number on their helmets Friday." The school has 1,400 students, two other counselors, a school psychologist, and no substitute coverage. Several students who were close to him are already in the building. The district crisis team is 40 minutes away. You have 45 minutes before the first bell.
1. What do you advise the principal about the assembly, the video, and the T-shirt and helmet plans? Explain the reasoning using safe messaging and postvention principles.
Read the worked answer
I would advise against the assembly and against the video, and I would ask the principal to delay the T-shirt and helmet decision until the crisis team arrives. My reasoning is not that students should be silent; it is that large assemblies and dramatic tributes can increase identification with the deceased and spread risk among vulnerable students.
An assembly of 1,400 students is hard to control, and it invites the kind of public attention that can romanticize the death. The video may contain method or message details I cannot vet in 45 minutes. I would offer a short, scripted announcement read in first-period classes instead: acknowledge the death, express sympathy, state that suicide is complex and not caused by one thing, give the counseling location, and remind students that help is available. No method, no location, no note contents, no simple explanation.
The T-shirts and helmet decals are a memorialization decision, not an emergency decision. I would say: "I am not saying no forever. I am saying we should decide with the crisis team and a written memorial policy, because permanent or highly visible tributes can glamorize the death." A one-time, private act of support is different from a season-long helmet tribute that keeps the death in front of 1,400 students every week.
I would frame all of this as risk reduction, not censorship.
2. Outline your plan for the first day, including how you would deploy the three counselors, the psychologist, and the crisis team, and which students you would prioritize.
Read the worked answer
With 45 minutes, I would focus on structure and triage rather than trying to see everyone.
Before first bell: brief the staff in a standing five-minute meeting. Give them the script, tell them what not to say, and tell them how to refer a student. Assign one counselor to each of three locations: the main counseling office, a quiet room near the library, and a room for students who need to leave class. The psychologist covers triage and consultation. The crisis team, when it arrives, takes the highest-risk students and supports staff.
Announcement: read in first period by teachers, not over the loudspeaker if the school typically uses loudspeakers for routine matters. The script should be brief and factual.
Priority students: (1) close friends and teammates, (2) students with known prior suicide attempts or current depression, (3) students who saw the Instagram posts and are reacting intensely, (4) students who were in conflict with the deceased or who feel guilty, and (5) students who ask for help. I would not wait for students to self-identify. I would ask teachers for names and pull those students for a check-in.
I would assign one adult to monitor social media and report escalating posts. The crisis team can handle parent calls and outside referrals. The key is that no student in acute distress waits in a long line.
3. What communication would you prepare for staff and parents, and what would you deliberately leave out?
Read the worked answer
For staff, I would prepare a one-page sheet with the announcement script, warning signs to watch for, the referral process, and the locations of support rooms. I would include concrete language: "If a student says they are thinking about suicide, do not leave them alone; call the counseling office and stay with them." I would also tell staff what not to do: do not speculate about causes, do not share method details, do not tell students to "be strong," and do not promise confidentiality.
For parents, I would send a short message the same day. It would acknowledge the death, express condolences, explain that counselors are available, give the warning signs, provide local and national crisis resources, and encourage parents to limit their children's exposure to graphic social media. I would include guidance on talking to children about suicide without details.
I would deliberately leave out: the method, the location, the contents of any note, speculation about family or bullying, and any suggestion that the death was preventable by a single action. I would also avoid naming the student in a mass email if the family has not consented, and I would not describe the death as a "choice" or a "solution." The purpose is to reduce contagion and open help-seeking, not to satisfy curiosity.