The 21st Birthday, the Medication, and the Keys
It is 8:30 p.m. Friday at a Raleigh restaurant holding a mixed beverage permit. A party of six is celebrating Dana's 21st birthday, and her NC license is valid, with a birth date that confirms she turned 21 at midnight. In about two hours she has had three margaritas and a full dinner. At the table she announces, loudly enough to carry across the bar, that she took her prescribed alprazolam about an hour before arriving, then says she is going to be wrecked. Her volume is climbing, she has knocked over a water glass, and she is laughing and crying within the same minute. Her older sister says, 'She's a lightweight, she's totally fine.' Dana orders a fourth margarita and tells the table she is driving four of them home, jingling the keys. A friend orders a birthday shot, and Dana's 20-year-old cousin orders a beer because it is a family party.
1. Do you serve the fourth margarita or the birthday shot? Dana is legally 21 tonight.
Read the worked answer
Refuse both. Age stopped being the issue at midnight; condition is the issue now. Three margaritas over two hours with a full dinner may well leave an adult under the legal limit, but the standard is not a number. It is whether the guest is intoxicated, and Dana has announced a benzodiazepine plus alcohol and then produced a cluster of visible signs: rising volume, a broken glass, laughing and crying within a minute. Alprazolam and alcohol together suppress the central nervous system more than either alone, impairing coordination and judgment at BACs that would otherwise look mild. You do not have to prove a BAC; you describe what you see. Script: 'I'm not serving you another drink tonight, but here's water and I'll bring dessert.' Then tell the manager and the other servers, so nobody quietly serves her while you are in the weeds.
2. The 20-year-old cousin orders a beer and the table argues that it is a family party. How do you respond, and what is the operational risk?
Read the worked answer
It is a flat no. He is 20, and North Carolina provides no family-consent exception on licensed premises, whether or not a parent is at the table and whether or not everyone else is drinking. The real risk is not this refusal; it is the second order. A 20-year-old at a table of six will simply ask a different server, and a busy Friday floor is where underage sales actually happen. So the refusal is only half the job: tell the other servers and the manager that table 12 includes a 20-year-old, and ask them to run any drink order from that table past you. If the table pushes, keep it short and do not debate the statute at the table. 'He's 20, I can't serve him, and I'm not going to argue about it' is enough. Log it.
3. Dana says she is driving four people home. What can you actually do, and what should you document?
Read the worked answer
The keys matter more than the drink. You cannot take her keys by force or detain her, but you can do several things in order. First, refuse service, which removes the next increment. Second, tell the manager and speak directly to the sister by name: 'She has had three drinks plus her medication and she says she is driving.' Third, offer concrete alternatives: a cab or rideshare the house will call, a sober friend, or letting the group sit in the dining room for a while. Fourth, if she gets behind the wheel and drives, call 911 with the make, model, plate, and direction; impaired-driving calls get dispatched. Document times, what you observed, and who you told. For an adult guest North Carolina has no general dram shop statute, but a server still faces criminal exposure under G.S. 18B-302 and the house faces ABC permit action.