The Altered Card and the Car Full of Friends
It is 11:20 p.m. Friday at a convenience store in Wilmington. Three young men come in, and the tallest, bearded and about 6-foot-2, sets a 30-pack of beer on the counter and hands you a North Carolina driver license. The date of birth would make him 22, and the photo resembles him. But the birth-date digits sit slightly above the baseline of the rest of the text and in a different font weight, the laminate is lifting at one corner, and the spacing in the license number looks uneven. The two friends behind him look 17; one is holding a Mountain Dew bottle and the other has just handed him folded cash and said, 'get the big one.' As they argue, a woman in her forties comes in, picks up a bottle of wine, and mentions she is getting it for the boys in the car. The store has one camera over the register and a policy manual under the counter.
1. Do you accept the license? What standard are you applying?
Read the worked answer
Refuse. The good-faith defense exists for sellers who rely on an ID that appears valid, and it disappears when the document shows objective signs of alteration: a birth date in a different font weight, sitting off the baseline, under lifting laminate. That is a judgment about the card, not about his beard or his height. A genuine NC license has consistent type, an even seal, and a fixed number format. Ask for a second document (passport, military ID, another state card) and, if there is none, decline. Keep your tone level: 'I can't take this one, it doesn't look right.' Do not accuse him of a crime in front of the store; you are refusing a sale, not making an arrest. Note the time, the name and number on the card, and the specific defects.
2. Can you keep the ID or chase him out to the lot? What is the right move after the refusal?
Read the worked answer
Do not grab it. North Carolina gives a store clerk no authority to seize someone's identification, and if you are wrong the store has taken a real license from a lawful adult. Some chains' policies allow holding an obvious fake to hand to ALE; if yours does, follow it exactly and turn it over the same shift. Otherwise refuse, let him leave, and document. Call the non-emergency police or ALE line if he becomes aggressive or the group lingers in the lot. Never follow him outside or block the door; a 30-pack is not worth an assault charge. Write up the description and the time, tell the next shift, and keep the beer where they cannot simply lift it. Fake-ID groups usually work a route, so the next store may be the target ten minutes later.
3. The woman in her forties says the wine is for the boys in the car. Can you sell it to her?
Read the worked answer
This one is genuinely harder, because she is of age and buying wine is lawful for her. But she has told you the purchase is for people in the car who look 17, and selling to an adult you know intends to hand it to minors is the shoulder-tap pattern: the adult absorbs the ID check and the alcohol goes to kids. There is no duty to complete any sale, so you may decline, as long as the reason is the apparent third-party transfer and not the customer's race, sex, or religion. Do not accuse her; ask a direct question and listen: 'Are those your sons out there?' If she confirms, decline, log it, and tell the manager. If she is buying for herself, sell it. Ambiguity is not proof; document what you saw and were told either way.